Articles | Volume 21, issue 18
https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-21-14019-2021
© Author(s) 2021. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Exceptional loss in ozone in the Arctic winter/spring of 2019/2020
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 21 Sep 2021)
- Supplement to the final revised paper
- Preprint (discussion started on 24 Feb 2021)
- Supplement to the preprint
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on acp-2020-1313', Anonymous Referee #2, 25 Mar 2021
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath, 07 Jul 2021
-
RC2: 'Review of acp-2020-1313', Anonymous Referee #1, 29 Mar 2021
- AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath, 07 Jul 2021
-
CC1: 'Comment on acp-2020-1313', Gloria Manney, 31 Mar 2021
- AC3: 'Reply on CC1', Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath, 07 Jul 2021
- AC4: 'Revised MS', Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath, 07 Jul 2021
- AC5: 'Supporting info', Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath, 07 Jul 2021
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
AR by Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath on behalf of the Authors (07 Jul 2021)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Referee Nomination & Report Request started (12 Jul 2021) by Michel Van Roozendael
RR by Anonymous Referee #1 (24 Jul 2021)
ED: Publish subject to minor revisions (review by editor) (24 Jul 2021) by Michel Van Roozendael
AR by Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath on behalf of the Authors (28 Jul 2021)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Publish as is (09 Aug 2021) by Michel Van Roozendael
AR by Jayanarayanan Kuttippurath on behalf of the Authors (12 Aug 2021)
Manuscript
I struggled with this review because while the paper presents a lot of information, and the authors have done a lot of work, it is difficult to see what is new. The major discoveries announced in the abstract, for example, “Sporadic occurrences of ozone hole values … record-breaking ozone loss of about 2.0–3.4 ppmv … unprecedented chlorine activation … first-ever appearance of loss [near] saturation in the Arctic…” have been made, and published, by Manney et al. (2020) or Woltmann et al. (2020). The title (“on the verge”) suggests that the authors think we will see a real ozone hole, or more ozone holes in the future. But they fail to present any dynamical arguments for that. Figure 1a of Woltmann et al. (2020) in fact suggests this, so it would be interesting to see a climate model prediction of the like, or more long-term analysis of trends in dynamical parameters.
Instead, the paper waffles back and forth about whether there was an “ozone hole” in 2020, even contradicting itself, e.g., “all the methods, data, and parameters converge to provide an undeniable fact of the first-ever ozone hole” and then “the ozone loss in the Arctic cannot not be called as “an ozone hole”.” In any case, this is not an important scientific argument, but a quibble about terminology.
Figure 3 is very nice, with a lot of important information, but that information is already in Manney et al. (2020). The ozonesondes, and the degree to which loss saturation was approached, are thoroughly presented in Woltmann et al. (2020). Loss saturation was never reached, in fact: Antarctic ozone hole profiles frequently show ozone below the detection limit of the sondes (~1 ppbv), while the lowest observed last spring in the Arctic was 125 ppbv. Sondes can measure ozone levels below 100 ppbv with good accuracy (as they do in the troposphere).
I did, however, find the discussion of the ozone mini-holes in December 2019 and January 2020 quite intriguing, especially the observation that they contained high ClO. Mini-holes are generally regarded as dynamic phenomena, so the suggestion that heterogeneous chemistry is occurring is interesting. It might be interesting to explore this further: are they also becoming more common? Do they affect the overall loss of ozone? See also Stenke and Grewe (2003). I noted that in Figure 7 the mini-holes were the only point where TCO fell below 220 DU. That seems worth exploring.
I also appreciated the long-term comparison with previous years in Figure 6. Perhaps this could expanded, along with an analysis of the long-term changes in vortex temperature, V_PSC, wave disturbances/stability…
Minor points:
Line 23: “provided the stratospheric chlorine levels still stay high there.” I don’t think there is much uncertainty about future Cl levels.
Line 34: “because”? Perhaps “possibly because”. This is far from certain, or we wouldn’t still be producing ozone assessments. In fact a lot of data show the opposite (decline since 1997).
Lines 58-59: “ Here, we show that the Arctic winter in 2020 … met the condition for an ozone hole for the first time”. What condition? This disagrees with most other assessments (e.g. Woltmann et al., 2020; Manney et al., 2020; Wilka et al., 2021).
Lines 60-65: Should indicate where the data were obtained. Uncertainties are quoted but no citation is given.
Line 80: “The missing values in satellite measurements were filled with linear interpolation (poison_grid_fill).” What is “poison_grid_fill”? How does it work? What are the criteria used for filling?
Line 120: A lot of this paragraph is confusing, but this line especially. T_NAT is 195, not 200 K.
Line 133-134: “This is the largest ice PSC ever observed in terms of its area, volume and number of days of appearance (i.e. frequency) in the Arctic and the area is twice that of the winter 2011.” So what? This information is never used for anything.
Lines 151-156: This is interesting, potentially, but vague and hand-waving. It could be really valuable to have an analysis that looks at the evolution and variation of the Arctic vortex over the last 20+ years.
Lines 210-212: This analysis might make an interesting paper, if expanded.
Lines 360-364: This interpretation is incorrect. The sondes do indeed have an uncertainty of about 10%, but that means that the minima of 0.125 (or 0.200) ppmv would have error bars of ±0.012 (or ±0.020). That is not consistent with zero, or even 0.1 ppmv.
Reference
Stenke, A., and V. Grewe (2003), Impact of ozone mini-holes on the heterogeneous destruction of stratospheric ozone, Chemosphere, 50, 177-190, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0045-6535(02)00599-4