The role of plume-scale processes in long-term impacts of aircraft emissions
- Laboratory for Aviation and the Environment, Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Correspondence: Sebastian D. Eastham (email@example.com)
Emissions from aircraft engines contribute to atmospheric NOx, driving changes in both the climate and in surface air quality. Existing atmospheric models typically assume instant dilution of emissions into large-scale grid cells, neglecting non-linear, small-scale processes occurring in aircraft wakes. They also do not explicitly simulate the formation of ice crystals, which could drive local chemical processing. This assumption may lead to errors in estimates of aircraft-attributable ozone production, and in turn to biased estimates of aviation's current impacts on the atmosphere and the effect of future changes in emissions. This includes black carbon emissions, on which contrail ice forms. These emissions are expected to reduce as biofuel usage increases, but their chemical effects are not well captured by existing models.
To address this problem, we develop a Lagrangian model that explicitly models the chemical and microphysical evolution of an aircraft plume. It includes a unified tropospheric–stratospheric chemical mechanism that incorporates heterogeneous chemistry on background and aircraft-induced aerosols. Microphysical processes are also simulated, including the formation, persistence, and chemical influence of contrails. The plume model is used to quantify how the long-term (24 h) atmospheric chemical response to an aircraft plume varies in response to different environmental conditions, engine characteristics, and fuel properties. We find that an instant-dilution model consistently overestimates ozone production compared to the plume model, up to a maximum error of ∼200 % at cruise altitudes. Instant dilution of emissions also underestimates the fraction of remaining NOx, although the magnitude and sign of the error vary with season, altitude, and latitude. We also quantify how changes in black carbon emissions affect plume behavior. Our results suggest that a 50 % reduction in black carbon emissions, as may be possible through blending with certain biofuels, may lead to thinner, shorter-lived contrails. For the cases that we modeled, these contrails sublimate ∼5 % to 15 % sooner and are 10 % to 22 % optically thinner. The conversion of emitted NOx to HNO3 and N2O5 falls by 16 % and 33 %, respectively, resulting in chemical feedbacks that are not resolved by instant-dilution approaches. The persistent discrepancies between results from the instant-dilution approach and from the aircraft plume model demonstrate that a parameterization of effective emission indices should be incorporated into 3-D atmospheric chemistry transport models.
Worldwide air passenger traffic is projected to grow at an annual rate of 5 % over the next two decades (Airbus, 2017; Boeing, 2017). Commercial aviation fuel usage has continuously increased (Mazraati, 2010) as demand for air transport has outpaced improvements in efficiency (Lee et al., 2001). Combined with difficulties in reducing emissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) from aircraft engines, aviation has a unique and growing influence on the chemical composition of the atmosphere.
The release of chemically reactive substances from aircraft exhausts induces perturbations in the environmental chemical balance that can persist for days (Meijer, 2001). Additionally, aviation is a unique sector in terms of its environmental challenges as it is the most significant anthropogenic source of pollution at high altitude (8–12 km). In 2015, an estimated 240 Tg of jet fuel were burned for commercial aviation according to the global inventory from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Aviation Environmental Design Tool (AEDT). For comparison, even under a very conservative assumption – that every rocket launch in 2015 was performed with the high-capacity, kerosene-burning Falcon Heavy – we estimate that rockets burned at most 11 Gg of fuel below the stratopause in that year. Nitrogen oxides (NOx = NO + NO2) released from aircraft engines have been estimated to increase ozone concentrations in the Northern Hemisphere by 2 % to 9 % (Penner et al., 1999; Schumann, 1997; Brasseur et al., 1996), while the ice clouds that form in aircraft exhausts (“contrails”) have been estimated as having climate impacts of the same order of magnitude as the carbon-dioxide released in the plume (Kärcher, 2018).
The chemical effects of these emissions are typically simulated using global, Eulerian, 3-D atmospheric chemistry transport models. These models simulate aircraft exhaust as being released instantaneously into homogeneously mixed grid cells that are orders of magnitude larger than the aircraft plume (Brasseur et al., 1998; Meijer et al., 2000; Eyring et al., 2007). This approach does not explicitly capture the high initial species concentrations within the plume, including the effects of non-linear chemistry in the early stages or the formation (and chemical effects) of aerosols and ice crystals (i.e., contrails) in the exhaust plumes. Shortly after release into the atmosphere, species concentrations in the aircraft plume can be several orders of magnitude larger than their background levels. NOx concentrations at cruise altitude can exceed values up to 20 ppbv in the early stages of the plume, whereas background NOx levels are typically between 0.007 and 0.15 ppbv in flight corridor such as the North Atlantic flight corridor (NAFC) (Schumann et al., 1998).
The impact of plume-scale modeling of aircraft wakes has been investigated over the past few decades mostly for its relevance to the environmental impact of aviation (Hidalgo, 1974; Thompson et al., 1996). Paoli et al. (2011) extensively covers the different approaches adopted to account for plume-scale effects. They also list previous efforts to incorporate plume-scale processing of aircraft emissions into global chemistry transport models. Prior studies have explicitly modeled the gas-phase components of the plume and have shown that the “instant-dilution” approach results in inaccurate estimation of the plume's chemical effects on the environment (Petry et al., 1998; Kraabøl et al., 2000; Cariolle et al., 2009; Huszar et al., 2013). Furthermore, the effects of interactions between contrail ice and the plume chemistry – including as a surface for rapid heterogeneous chemistry – have not yet been quantified.
Field measurements over the past decades, such as the SUCCESS (Toon and Miake-Lye, 1998), POLINAT (Schumann et al., 2000) and SULFUR experiments (Schumann et al., 2002), have measured the microphysical characteristics of both liquid aerosol and ice particles (contrails) in aircraft plumes. Contrail modeling efforts based on these measurements have shown that these aerosols are sensitive to ambient relative humidity, fuel sulfur content, and the amount of emitted solid particles (Kärcher, 1998; Wong and Miake-Lye, 2010). In the early stages, non-volatile aerosols take up a significant amount of the emitted water vapor through condensation and heterogeneous freezing, potentially leading to the formation of liquid aerosols and ice crystals. During the plume expansion regime, gas species react and diffuse, potentially reacting with one another through heterogeneous chemistry on their surface. This suggests that the formation of ice in aircraft exhausts may result in additional chemical processing that is not captured in either global atmospheric models or gas-phase aircraft plume models.
This gap also affects assessment of new fuels for aviation. Biofuels have been identified as an option to reduce aviation's climate impacts by reducing the net contribution of aviation to atmospheric CO2. However, several of these alternative fuels are also expected to produce less black carbon (Speth et al., 2015) and to have a lower sulfur content (Gupta et al., 2010; Rojo et al., 2015). The effect that these changes will have on aircraft plume chemistry and contrail evolution – and therefore on the total environmental impact of aircraft emissions – depend on the microphysical response of the plume. As such, the atmospheric effects of changing from conventional jet fuel to alternative fuels are not yet fully understood. In the following, soot emissions are identified as black carbon emissions.
To address these issues, we develop the Aircraft Plume Chemistry, Emissions, and Microphysics Model (APCEMM). APCEMM is applied under a variety of conditions to simulate the influence of changes in environment, aircraft characteristics, and fuel properties on in-plume chemistry and aerosol size distribution. Finally, the effects of these changes are presented in terms of their impact on large-scale properties such as net 24 h ozone production, end-of-lifetime NOx partitioning, and contrail optical thickness.
We first describe the overall modeling approach used by APCEMM to simulate the chemistry and physics of an aircraft plume (Sect. 2.1). Section 2.2 and 2.3 describe the details of the different models used for the initial and mature-plume evolution phases, respectively. Finally, Sect. 2.4 describes the experimental design used to determine the overall impact of plume-scale processes on long-term aircraft emissions impacts. In this paper, APCEMM is used to quantify the role of non-linear plume chemistry and to obtain a first estimate of contrail impacts on chemistry. Estimating precisely the interdependence of contrail microphysics and chemistry would require expensive large eddy simulations (LESs). Using simplifying assumptions regarding plume dynamics, APCEMM aims to bridge the gap between Gaussian plume models and LESs.
2.1 Model overview
APCEMM models the growth and chemical evolution of a single aircraft plume. Chemical concentrations and aerosol characteristics are calculated for a 2-D cross section of the plume, perpendicular to the flight path. Dynamics, chemistry, and microphysics are explicitly modeled within the plume, using two different approaches depending on the age of the plume.
Observations and high-resolution modeling of aircraft wakes have shown three dynamical regimes in the first few minutes after emission, before the wake develops into a “mature” plume. Typical timescales and dilution ratios for an aircraft plume are shown in Table 1.
During the initial “early jet” and “jet” regimes, compressibility effects arise from the momentum-driven jet that last for a short amount of time of the order of a few seconds (Kärcher, 1995). After ∼10 s, the wing-tip vortices form and begin to affect the emissions plume. During this “vortex regime”, the counter-rotating vortex pair causes the plume to descend by distances of the order of several hundred meters (Kärcher, 1995; Schumann, 2012). The wake is prone to instabilities triggered by atmospheric or aircraft-induced turbulence. Crow instability can occur in aircraft plumes and cause small sinusoidal distortions in the vortex shape to be amplified (Paoli and Shariff, 2016). These enhanced oscillations cause the vortex system to collapse (Naiman et al., 2011). We do not explicitly simulate these processes, instead treating the early plume as well mixed.
Over the period of these three initial regimes, the plume cools rapidly to ambient temperatures (∼220 K) from an initial temperature of 500–600 K, leading to a spike in ice and liquid water saturations approximately 100 ms after emission and triggering a range of microphysical processes (Kärcher et al., 2015). During this period, formation of sulfate aerosols, freezing on solid nuclei, condensation, heterogeneous nucleation, and coagulation also occur. Homogeneous freezing is not included. Previous studies have suggested that homogeneous freezing is unlikely in aircraft plumes given the number of pre-existing nuclei (Wong and Miake-Lye, 2010). This is because combustion particles can acquire an ice coating at temperatures much higher than cruise temperatures, implying that ice crystals formed in the vicinity of the engines freeze by virtue of heterogeneous nucleation. In APCEMM, the plume is assumed to be well mixed during these first three regimes – the “early-plume phase” (Sect. 2.2). We model this early plume as a uniform, well-mixed air mass evolving through time. In the following, we refer to this early-plume representation as a “box model”.
The output of this box model is then provided as the initial condition for the model of the long-term diffusion regime (Sect. 2.3). This regime begins when the aircraft-induced vortices break apart. In this regime, the plume expands in ambient air. The rate of diffusion is controlled by the vertical stratification of the atmosphere and by the vertical gradient of the wind speed (wind shear). Unlike the early-plume phase, spatial heterogeneity of the plume is explicitly accounted for in APCEMM during the diffusion regime, allowing for cross-plume concentration gradients. For the first hour of this regime, we simulate an upward motion of the plume. This is because the vortex sinking, modeled as a simple vertical displacement, results in adiabatic compression of the plume. In a stably stratified atmosphere, this causes the plume to be warmer than its surroundings. The resulting buoyancy and radiative imbalance causes the plume to rise back to its original emission altitude, which we simulate as taking place over a 1 h timescale (Heymsfield et al., 1998).
2.2 Modeling of the early plume
During the early-plume phase, the plume is treated as a single, well-mixed air mass. The air mass grows, dilutes, and cools through turbulent mixing with ambient air (entrainment). It also sinks and heats up due to the effect of the aircraft wing-tip vortices (vortex sinking). Throughout this phase, we simulate rapid chemical changes, including the formation of liquid and solid aerosols.
2.2.1 Dilution and temperature evolution of the early plume
In the jet and vortex regimes, we adopt a formulation similar to the box model used in Kärcher (1995). The rate of change of chemical concentrations within the plume is dominated in this regime by dilution due to turbulent mixing. The contribution of wake mixing is approximated as a first-order decay term proportional to a time-dependent entrainment rate, i.e., ωC(t).
where Ck is the molecular concentration of species k.
This entrainment rate agrees with the experimental data and curve fit provided in Schumann et al. (1998) for times greater than 1 s. CAmb,k is the ambient molecular concentration of species k and is assumed to be constant during the jet and vortex regimes considering that the timescale associated with gas-phase chemistry is much greater than the time taken to reach the diffusion regime. We assume that, during this time, gas-phase chemistry does not influence the concentrations of most species within the plume. The only exceptions are conversion of S(IV) to S(VI) and NOx to HONO and HNO3, as described in Sect. 2.2.2, which evolve on similar timescales due to high initial concentrations (Kärcher et al., 1996).
The temperature of the plume during this initial phase is controlled by two processes. Firstly, prior experiments have shown that typical Lewis numbers are close to unity in coaxial jets, such as aircraft plumes (Forstall and Shapiro, 1950). Mixing of cold air with the hot exhaust stream (cooling the plume) is therefore assumed to occur at the same rate as entrainment of ambient chemical species. Secondly, the downward motion induced by the wing-tip vortices also causes the air to heat up adiabatically, independently of the local lapse rate (Unterstrasser et al., 2008). The plume temperature evolution is therefore expressed as the sum of a positive heating due to vortex sinking and a first-order decay term representing entrainment, i.e.,
In the present section, units are provided for the purpose of demonstration only and are not fundamental to the formulae. In Eq. (2), Tp is the plume temperature in K, Γd the adiabatic lapse rate expressed in K m−1, vz the vertical velocity in m s−1 of the plume, and TAmb the ambient temperature in K evaluated as a function of the ambient lapse rate, which has been obtained as a function of latitude and altitude from monthly averaged meteorological data obtained from the Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research and Applications, Version 2 (MERRA-2). The plume acquires a vertical motion during the vortex regime such that vz is assumed to be non-zero only between the time at which the vortices start inducing a vertical displacement of the plume and the vortex breakup time. The wake vortex sinking is computed according to a parametric formulation described in Schumann (2012) from which we evaluate the mean downward displacement as a function of aircraft and ambient atmospheric characteristics. This parameterization of the aircraft-induced mixing does not allow us to accurately capture the vortex dynamics and neglects the spatial heterogeneity that could arise. The inclusion of a more accurate representation of the early-plume dynamics in APCEMM is an area for future development.
2.2.2 Chemical conversions in the early plume
In the early stages of the plume, oxidation of NO and NO2 results in the formation of HONO and HNO3. As described in Kärcher (1999), conversion efficiencies of NO, NO2 and SO2 depend on the exit plane hydroxyl radical concentration. Tremmel et al. (1998) inferred initial OH concentrations at the combustor and engine exit through measurements of NO, HONO, and HNO3, as well as CO2 to account for plume dilution. Their results indicate that the OH emission index ranges between 0.32 and 0.39 g kg for the JT9D-7A, which corresponds to an engine exit mixing ratio lying between 9.0 and 14.4 ppmv. Conversion efficiencies used in APCEMM are depicted in Table 2. Even though the conversion efficiencies remain of the order of a few percent, they increase monotonically with the OH engine exit mixing ratio, as more radicals are available for the following reactions (Kärcher et al., 1996).
Oxidation of S(IV) to gaseous S(VI) is not simulated during this period. This process mostly occurs in the engine's turbines and only a negligible fraction is converted in the young aircraft plume (Lukachko et al., 1998; Tremmel and Schumann, 1999).
2.2.3 Microphysical representation of the early plume
As the plume cools down and mixes with ambient air, aerosols begin to form, supplementing those that were emitted directly from the engine (e.g., black carbon particles). This both modifies the local chemical concentrations and changes the initial aerosol size distribution during the second phase of the plume. Four microphysical processes are explicitly considered: freezing of liquid particles into solid ones, condensation of gas onto liquid particles, nucleation of new liquid particles, and coagulation of both solid and liquid particles.
We first consider growth of an existing particle population. The mathematical formulation is given in detail in Appendix A but is covered briefly here. The microphysical model for growth of ice particles is adapted from Kärcher (1998). According to Kärcher and Yu (2009) and in situ measurements of black carbon number emissions at cruise altitude from Petzold et al. (1999), the plume is in a “soot-rich” regime, favoring freezing of water around black carbon cores rather than freezing of liquid and ambient particles. We thus assume that solid particles (black carbon and metal) emitted by the aircraft serve as condensation nuclei for water vapor. Under supersaturated conditions, deposition induces ice crystal growth, depleting gaseous water vapor. During this initial phase, ice crystals are treated as monodisperse (single size) and are considered spherical. Under these assumptions, we need only consider the growth of a single “representative” particle, rather than analyzing the population as a whole. Because of the low ambient temperatures, water that condenses is assumed to freeze instantaneously, such that ice crystals grow by deposition of water molecules onto their surface. The rate of change in the ice mass of a particle, mp, is then given by
where is a function accounting for nucleus activation (Eq. A3), Cp is the ice crystal capacitance (equal to the particle radius rp for spherical nuclei), Dv,eff is the effective water vapor diffusion coefficient in air (Eq. A4), and is the water partial pressure. Assuming that each ice particle is nucleated on a black carbon particle with a dry radius of 20 nm, and using a fixed mass density for ice of 916.7 kg m3, this calculation also gives the rate of change of radius of solid particles in the plume. Calculation of each of the terms in Eq. (3) is described in Appendix A1.
Black carbon and ice particles can also grow by condensation of water vapor, sulfuric acid, and nitric acid into a partial liquid surface layer. The growth of this layer is related to the condensation (or evaporation) rate of H2O, H2SO4, and HNO3, calculated as
where Nk,p is the number of molecules of type k on a particle of type p, Dk is the gas diffusivity in m2 s−1, and Pk and are the partial and saturation pressures of species k, respectively, expressed in Pa. The function β accounts for changes in uptake in different gas regimes and is described in Eq. (A5). Experimentally derived deposition coefficients for heteromolecular condensation, used in the calculation of β, are taken from Kärcher (1998). On black carbon particles, θ describes the fractional surface coverage of the particle liquid coating and is calculated according to Kärcher (1998). For all other particles, this limitation is ignored and θ is set to 1. Gas diffusivities for H2SO4 and HNO3 are taken from Tang et al. (2014).
Similar to sulfur, organic compounds in the upper troposphere have been found to alter the freezing behavior of aerosols and the black carbon coating fraction, θ, even in natural conditions (Cziczo et al., 2004; Kärcher and Koop, 2005; Murray et al., 2010). In aircraft plumes, the formation of condensable organic species originates in the production of electrically charged clusters (chemi-ions) (Kärcher et al., 2015). These organic compounds have been found to be either aqueous aerosols or soluble in aqueous H2SO4 solutions (Yu et al., 1999; Kärcher et al., 2015). Their high solubility makes organic matter a prime contributor to the mass of ultrafine plume particles and could also enhance the black carbon particle coating (Rojo et al., 2015). Previous studies estimated the mass of particulate organic matter in aqueous form to be approximately 20 mg kg (Kärcher et al., 2000). The theory behind the role of organics on particle growth and their chemical speciation is still limited. In most of the experiments described in this paper, we neglect the role of organic aerosol. However, as a sensitivity study, we estimate the effect of organic matter on the fractional coating by prescribing an initial fraction of coated black carbon (Sect. 3.1). We also perform simulations in which we calculate the effect of changes in black carbon emissions. These simulations can be considered as a proxy for the effect of organic aerosol if the aerosols are capable of acting as ice nuclei (Sect. 3.1.3).
In addition to growth of existing particles, new liquid particles can form through binary homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation. Several nucleation parameterizations have been established to simulate binary homogeneous nucleation in a sulfur-rich environment (Jaecker-Voirol and Mirabel, 1989; Napari et al., 2002; Vehkamäki et al., 2002). Jung et al. (2008) have computed different sensitivities using these models and provided further validation of the models cited previously, comparing the results to field measurements. Given the range of ambient conditions relevant to an aircraft plume, we calculate cluster size, composition, and nucleation rate using the parameterization from Vehkamäki et al. (2002). While this model is only considered valid between 230.15 and 305.15 K, we expect that most nucleation of fresh sulfate aerosol will occur while the plume is still cooling down, within this temperature range. Liquid aerosols are assumed to remain liquid throughout the plume lifetime. Previous studies (e.g., Kärcher, 1998; Tabazadeh et al., 1997) have quantified the freezing behavior of sulfate aerosols and liquid sulfur coating at low temperatures and found that freezing of sulfate aerosols requires an ice supersaturation of about 1.5 at 210 K. Additionally, Kärcher et al. (1998) conclude that heterogeneous freezing on coated black carbon particles drives the contrail formation phase. We thus neglect the freezing of sulfate aerosols similarly to Wong and Miake-Lye (2010).
The number concentration of aerosol particles in the plume can also change through coagulation, as emitted and entrained particles collide and coalesce. During the early-plume phase, we consider only the coagulation of liquid aerosols and the scavenging of liquid aerosols by ice and black carbon particles. Self-aggregation of ice and black carbon particles on the timescale of the early plume is assumed to be negligible. Since all aerosols during this phase are likely to be small, all collisions are assumed to result in coagulation (a coalescence efficiency of 1) (Jacobson, 2011). Particle breakup and shattering are neglected for the same reason (Beard and Ochs III, 1995; Jacobson, 2011). The effect of coagulation on the number concentration of aerosols in size bin k, covering the size interval , is modeled as
where nk is the number density of particles in bin k and Ki,j is the coagulation kernel appropriate to collisions between size bins i and j, which represents the physics of the problem. A full description of the coagulation kernel and its calculation is given in Appendix B. Equation (5) states that the rate of change in the number density in bin k corresponds to the rate at which smaller particles of size k-j coagulate with particles of size j minus the rate at which the particles of size k are lost due to coagulation with particles of all sizes.
During the early-plume phase, liquid aerosols are modeled using 64 size bins, from a minimum radius of 0.1 nm to a maximum of 0.5 µm. Ice and black carbon aerosols are considered to have a single size, as estimated based on Eqs. (3) and (4). Instead of solving Eq. (5) directly for every size bin, aerosol coagulation is computed using a semi-implicit, non-iterative, volume-conserving and unconditionally stable numerical scheme described in Jacobson et al. (1994). This model has been used extensively in aerosol modeling and aircraft plume simulations (Paoli et al., 2008). The rate of particle coagulation peaks shortly after emission and then significantly reduces as entrainment of ambient air into the plume decreases the number of aerosol particles present per unit volume of air.
The number and size of the aerosol particles present at the end of the early phase is used to provide the initial conditions for the mature-plume phase, with one adjustment. The downward movement induced by the aircraft wake vortices (Unterstrasser et al., 2008) increases the depth of the contrail, while adiabatic heating and turbulent temperature fluctuations result in crystal losses through sublimation. These losses are represented using a survival fraction, which we compute using a parameterization based on large eddy simulations (Unterstrasser, 2016). This survival fraction is typically of the order of 0.5, such that the initial aerosol population for the mature-plume phase includes roughly half the number of aerosol particles as were present at the end of the early phase.
2.3 Modeling of the mature plume
Following breakdown of the wing-tip vortices, the plume is considered to enter the “diffusion regime”. In this regime, the plume is no longer considered to be well mixed, and diffusion of chemical constituents becomes important.
In APCEMM, we use an operator splitting method that allows us to treat the chemical kinetics terms separately from the turbulent diffusion terms and to apply optimized solution methods for these different processes. For chemistry calculations, the domain is represented using a set of fixed concentric elliptical rings (Fig. 1). The central ring (semi-major and semi-minor axes of ∼75 and ∼30 m, respectively) is initialized using chemical concentrations and aerosol properties as calculated at the end of the early-plume stage (Sect. 2.2) and after accounting for losses due to vortex sinking. All other rings are initialized with ambient air. Each ring is further discretized into a lower and an upper half ring to allow for vertical variations in temperature and to account for sedimentation of aerosols.
Diffusion and advection of pollutants relative to the plume centerline (due to wind shear), in addition to sedimentation of aerosols and buoyant motion, are simulated on a regular, rectilinear grid with a horizontal and vertical grid spacing of ∼100 m horizontally and ∼5 m vertically. Prior to these “transport” processes, concentrations of constituents in the rings are mapped to the rectilinear grid. Diffusion, advection, and settling of the constituents are then simulated using a spectral scheme (Gottlieb and Orszag, 1977). This scheme is also used to allow shear to distort the chemical rings. Following transport, the constituents are mapped back to the ring discretization.
Diffusion of pollutants, chemistry, and aerosol microphysics are all explicitly accounted for using a time-stepping scheme. All processes are simulated using a variable time step. During the first 10 min, and within 10 min of local sunrise or sunset, the time step is restricted to 30 s to ensure that rapid chemical changes are captured. At all other times, a time step of 5 min is used.
2.3.1 Diffusion and shear in the mature plume
The rate of diffusion of the plume's constituents is modeled using directional diffusion coefficients. The degree of diffusion anisotropy is dictated by the Richardson number, a measure of local atmospheric stability (Dürbeck and Gerz, 1996; Schumann et al., 1998). In APCEMM, the vertical diffusion coefficient Dv is estimated using the approach from Schumann et al. (1995) using the local Brunt–Väisälä frequency and Richardson number, which is in turn computed from the local wind shear. To account for initial turbulence, Dv is increased to 1.1 m2 s−1, after which it is reduced exponentially to its background value with an e-folding time of 13 min (Kraabøl et al., 2000). The horizontal diffusion coefficient is required as an input to APCEMM. Dürbeck and Gerz (1996) found that, for Richardson numbers above unity, the horizontal and vertical diffusion coefficients lie in the range 15 m2 s and 0.15 m2 s m2 s−1, respectively, which agree with measurements from Schumann et al. (1995). Although computationally efficient, our current representation of the aircraft-induced turbulence is idealized and does not allow us to model the spatial heterogeneity that would arise after the dissipation of the vortex pair. A higher-fidelity approach would be needed to capture the effects of vortex structures on the optical and chemical properties of the plume.
In addition to diffusion across the domain, advection due to wind shear is explicitly accounted for using the same spectral scheme as is applied to simulate diffusion. The horizontal wind speed relative to the plume center line is calculated assuming a constant vertical wind shear across the domain.
Several physical processes can result in not only a vertical displacement but also a vertical stretching of an aircraft plume. Aircraft-induced vortex sinking leads to adiabatic compression and leads to the formation of spatially non-uniform primary and secondary wakes (Paoli and Shariff, 2016). Following the initial descent, the plume rises due to buoyancy. Simultaneously, the plume absorbs upwelling infrared radiation causing it to heat up relatively to the surrounding air (Jensen et al., 1998b). Non-uniformities in the local ice water content lead to a vertical stretching of the contrail. The contrail net heating drives a local plume updraft with speeds of up to 10 cm s−1 during the first hour (Heymsfield et al., 1998), consistent with estimates that the contrail core can rise over the first hour after its formation (Jensen et al., 1998b).
In this study, we adopt a simple representation of vertical plume motions. Vortex sinking is represented as a uniform-velocity downdraft over the first few minutes, as described in Sect. 2.2. We represent the effects of buoyancy by applying an exponentially decaying velocity profile, with the aim of resolving the vertical updraft. The time constant associated with the local updraft is 1 h (Jensen et al., 1998b; Heymsfield et al., 1998), such that an initial vertical speed of 10 cm s−1 has reduced to 6 cm s−1 within 30 min. Although simulation of large-scale synoptic uplift of the aircraft plume and surrounding air are possible in APCEMM, we do not include them in this paper.
This representation of vertical motions is highly simplified. The focus of this paper is to quantify the effect of plume-scale non-linear chemistry on the atmospheric impacts of aviation exhaust, including a first assessment of role played by contrail ice. Although APCEMM can also give some insight into the behavior of contrails, it is still an intermediate-fidelity tool between the widely used Gaussian plume approximation (Schumann, 2012) and computationally expensive large eddy simulations (Paugam et al., 2010; Sölch and Kärcher, 2010; Unterstrasser and Gierens, 2010a; Picot et al., 2015; Paoli et al., 2017). Future research using APCEMM to investigate the details of contrail evolution would benefit from the implementation of a more sophisticated representation of the plume's movement and internal dynamics.
2.3.2 Chemistry in the mature plume
The gas-phase chemistry mechanism is taken from GEOS-Chem v11 (Eastham et al., 2014). Heterogeneous halogen, N2O5, and HOx chemistry, as well as formation and evaporation of stratospheric aerosols are considered. Due to their long lifetimes, reactions involving chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) are neglected. The set of chemical reactions is solved numerically with the Kinetic Pre-Processor (KPP) (Damian et al., 2002). KPP is a software tool, which generates code from a set of chemical reactions and rate coefficients to integrate the differential equations and compute the time evolution of chemical species with a suitable numerical integration scheme.
2.3.3 Aerosol modeling in the mature plume
The aerosol distributions in the mature-plume phase are initialized based on the output from the early-plume module. The distribution of sulfate aerosols is unchanged while ice particles are distributed assuming a log-normal distribution, using the mean ice particle radius and a geometric standard deviation of 1.6 (Goodman et al., 1998; Jensen et al., 1998a). The use of a log-normal distribution is based on in situ measurements (Schröder et al., 2000) and this assumption has been used in previous work to initialize the contrail ice particle size distribution (Jensen et al., 1998b; Picot et al., 2015).
As the plume expands, the ice crystal size distribution changes due to growth, sublimation, gravitational settling, and coagulation. Even without the application of a log-normal distribution, a polydisperse distribution would arise due to coagulation and the different meteorological conditions throughout the plume. Particle growth is treated using a moving-center size structure (Jacobson, 1997). Ice crystal growth is characterized by the “advection” of the particle density distribution across diameter space (Jacobson, 2003).
Ice crystal growth modifies the particle volume but leaves the number of particles constant. Sublimation mechanisms lead to a loss of ice crystals and act as a source of water vapor, modifying the cell's relative humidity and release a dry particle core that is then considered “deactivated” and unable to take up water vapor as ice. The extent of sublimation is moderated by the size of the droplet cores, as larger hydrometeors can persist in subsaturated air. Evaporation and sublimation are both endothermic processes that cool down the surface of an ice crystal. The equilibrium surface temperature is obtained through an iterative process that allows us to compute the particle sublimation rate (Jacobson, 2003).
Aggregation of ice particles uses the same algorithm and the same coagulation kernel described previously for sulfate aerosols. Following the approach from Sölch and Kärcher (2010), we assume a constant aggregation efficiency for ice particles.
Gravitational settling causes the ice particles to fall vertically, thus entering warmer regions. Ice particle terminal velocities are computed according to Stokes law, accounting for the slip correction, as in Pruppacher and Klett (1998). The settling velocity of an ice crystal depends on its size, with larger particles falling faster. Different parts of a contrail have different crystal sizes, meaning that they settle at different speeds (Unterstrasser et al., 2017a). This differential settling effect is often neglected in reduced-order contrail models.
Finally, liquid (sulfate) aerosols are modeled using the same 64-bin approach as in the early-plume phase. In the mature-plume phase, the distribution of sulfate aerosols is affected only by coagulation, using the same coagulation kernel as before.
2.4 Experimental description
We first present the chemical and microphysical evolution of the plume in the first 15 min after emissions (Sect. 3.1), including the effect of changes in fuel sulfur content (FSC) and the potential role of condensable organic species. These factors are likely to be important for the formation and growth of ultrafine volatile particles and ice crystals in the aircraft wake. In addition, the theory behind the role of organic compounds is still poorly understood but Kärcher et al. (2000) estimate that particulate organic matter is a primary contributor to the mass of volatile particles. In this study, the impact of organic matter on the early evolution of black carbon particles and ice crystal growth is quantified by prescribing an initial fraction of coated black carbon. We also perform simulations to assess the role of the fuel sulfur content and the black carbon number emission index on the surface coating of black carbon particles and the formation of liquid sulfate particles. FSC varies from an average of ∼2 to 600 ppm, depending on fuel type (Rojo et al., 2015). A range of black carbon emissions has been measured in a number of different aircraft wakes and has been found to vary by an order of magnitude (11–100 mg kg, as estimated by Petzold et al., 1999). Results for different black carbon emission rates may also provide insight into the effect of organic aerosol, if said aerosol is acting as a nucleation site rather than as a coating for existing black carbon.
We then simulate the chemical evolution of a plume from a single flight using both approaches and compare the results to the literature (Sect. 3.2). We compute the impact of changes in background conditions (Sect. 3.3), engine emissions (Sect. 3.4), and flight location (Sect. 3.5). These simulations are intended to both validate the ability of APCEMM to accurately model non-linear plume chemistry and to quantify the extent to which the output of an instant-dilution approach differs from that of a fully resolved plume model.
We also perform a set of dedicated experiments to quantify the relationship between different parameters and the behavior of a contrail forming in the plume. This includes the role of relative humidity and contrail updraft velocity (Sect. 3.6.1), and the effect of changes in black carbon emissions (Sect. 3.6.2). Finally, we combine these assessments to determine how accounting for contrail ice could directly affect the chemistry of the plume, and how this effect is modified by changes in black carbon emissions (Sect. 3.6.3). Most global models do not include contrail simulation, so only APCEMM results are provided in these sections.
All plumes are simulated for 24 h. For typical diffusion parameters of Dh=15 m2 s−1 and Dv=0.15 m2 s−1, this results in 0.03 % of emitted material reaching the edge of the computational domain by the end of the simulation.
2.4.1 Model setup
Both models, APCEMM and the instant-dilution approach, are initialized with background mixing ratios obtained from a year-long GEOS-Chem simulation. Noontime photolysis rates are retrieved from that same run. Atmospheric background conditions are obtained from a spinup run over 5 d. Meteorological data for each altitude, latitude, longitude, and time are taken from the Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research and Applications version 2 (MERRA-2) for 2013. This includes the vertical wind shear and (longitudinally averaged) Brunt–Väisälä frequency, used for calculation of the vertical diffusion coefficient. This approach provides an upper bound on vertical diffusion, as it overpredicts the diffusion parameter at large Richardson numbers. The probability distribution of the Brunt–Väisälä frequency, Richardson number, and resulting vertical diffusion parameter are given in the Supplement for different pressure levels. As shown in Dürbeck and Gerz (1996), the Brunt–Väisälä distribution is unimodal in the troposphere and peaks around N=0.01 s−1. A second mode appears in the stratosphere at approximately N=0.02 s−1. Some further analysis shows that 90 % of the distribution lies at Richardson numbers greater than 5, indicating weak and/or fast-decaying turbulence. The distribution and its support agree with the values in Schumann et al. (1995) and the mean values lie in the range given by Dürbeck and Gerz (1996). A horizontal diffusion parameter Dh of 20 m2 s−1 is assumed for all simulations. Unless otherwise specified, we assume zero wind shear, although the effects of this assumption are investigated. A list of all the input parameters expected by APCEMM is provided in Table S1 of the Supplement.
All the cases in this analysis consider emissions from a B747-8 equipped with General Electric next-generation (GEnx) engines, which are released in the innermost ring, with a cross-sectional area of 6000 m2. The representation of the GEnx engines in APCEMM at cruise altitude uses the equations of the Boeing Fuel Flow Method2 (DuBois and Paynter, 2006) to compute a cruise NOx emission index from the ones provided by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Aircraft Engine Emissions Databank. For black carbon emissions, we use the “SN−CBC” method described in Stettler et al. (2013), Eq. (5) in their paper. The black carbon mass emission index varied from 10 to 14 mg kgfuel for this particular engine except in Sect. 3.1.3 and in 3.6.2, 3.6.3, and 3.6.4, where we prescribe different black carbon emission indices representing the heterogeneity in current cruise soot emissions. The emission rates for black carbon particles or “number emissions indices”, EI#, are derived from the mass indices EIm as
where ρBC, rBC, and σBC are the black carbon mass density, median radius, and geometric standard deviation. For all the cases described in this paper, we use a black carbon median radius of 20 nm and a geometric standard deviation equal to 1.6. This means that changes in the overall mass of black carbon emitted are modeled as a change in the number of particles.
The fuel sulfur content is kept constant at 500 ppm throughout all cases, except in Sect. 3.1.2, where we quantify the effect of changes in fuel sulfur content on the early-plume black carbon fractional coating and liquid sulfate aerosol formation and evolution. Analysis of results using other aircraft–engine combinations is a future research opportunity.
2.4.2 Metrics of the chemical response
To evaluate the error resulting from neglecting non-linear plume chemistry, we compare results generated using the instant-dilution approach and using APCEMM. The discrepancies between both models are first compared in terms of total ozone mass per unit length in flight direction (kg km−1). In addition, the conversion of short-lived nitrogen oxides to reservoir species affects long-term ozone production, heterogeneous chemistry, particle formation and/or growth, with known long-term impacts on air quality (Eastham and Barrett, 2016). The evolution of nitrogen partitioning is therefore computed for both models.
The total emitted NOy () is a conserved quantity throughout the plume lifetime and is equal to the plume-integrated NOy perturbation , where the notation [⋅]Amb refers to ambient conditions. At any given instant , which is proportional to the NOx emission index. Averaging the perturbation due to aircraft emissions allows us to compute the time-dependent chemical conversions from one species to another. The emission conversion factor of species X, ECFX, is then defined as
The emission conversion factor quantifies how many moles of species X are obtained for one mole of emitted NOy. For ozone, this is similar to the ozone production efficiency (OPE), although the ECF is time-dependent and does not include ozone that has been produced and later destroyed. Given that nitrogen oxides are converted to reservoir species over the plume lifetime, decreases with time.
We use the ECF to quantify the discrepancy between the two approaches. For a species X, we define the error as the difference in ECF after 24 h:
A positive error means that instant dilution of aircraft emissions overestimates the chemical production of species X compared to the aircraft plume model.
Evaluation after 24 h ensures that the domain is in the same photochemical state as at initialization. This guarantees that we make a fair comparison for photochemically active species. However, the plume may still be sufficiently concentrated that adding it to a grid cell in a larger simulation may still result in misrepresentation of plume chemistry. Additional work will be needed to quantify the magnitude of this error if plume processing is embedded into a global-scale model.
3.1 Results of the early-plume phase
In this section, we model the evolution of the plume in the first 15 min after initial emission. In addition to chemical effects, we quantify the role that organic matter, fuel sulfur content, and black carbon emissions have on the early size distribution of aerosols in the plume.
In these simulations, the background air is initially subsaturated with respect to water at a temperature of 215 K. As described in Sect. 2.2.3, organic matter influences the total mass of aqueous aerosols and the coating on black carbon particles, thus indirectly modifying the water deposition rate. Section 3.1.1 describes the early-plume microphysical evolution and quantifies the role of organic matter on particle growth. The formation of ultrafine volatile plume particles (composed of dissolved H2SO4 and organic compounds) modifies the gaseous composition of the plume and thus the condensation of soluble species on black carbon particles. Section 3.1.2 quantifies the sensitivity of the black carbon coating fraction to fuel sulfur content and examines the partitioning between liquid and gaseous H2SO4. An analogy is then used to identify the impact of organic aqueous aerosols on the black carbon surface composition. Section 3.1.3 then considers how changes in black carbon emissions affect its surface coating. The simulations carried out in this last section could also be used to provide some insight into a potential role for ultrafine organic particles at low temperatures. We consider these simulations and outcomes because of their relevance to the aged plume in terms of ice uptake, aerosol surface area, and contrail lifetime.
3.1.1 Early-plume evolution and role of organic matter
This section first describes the evolution of the aerosol size distribution during the early-plume phase, from the engine exit plane to approximately 15 min after initial emission. We then quantify one potential effect of organic species on plume chemistry and aerosol size distribution through their effect on black carbon surface composition, by varying the initial fractional coating between 0 % and 25 %.
Figure 2 displays the evolution of the early plume over different timescales. The air at the exit plane of the engine is assumed to be at a temperature of ∼550 K. The plume undergoes rapid cooling in the jet phase and fresh ambient air is entrained into the warm plume. As the temperature decreases, the plume reaches saturation and remains saturated for ∼2 s. During this time, rapid deposition of water increases the particle radius of ice nuclei (as shown in the upper-right plot). As plume mixing continues, fresh, dry air enters the plume. As the relative humidity with respect to ice falls below saturation, the particles start to sublimate. The loss of ice mass serves to maintain the plume's relative humidity at 100 % with respect to ice. This continues until all ice mass has melted, after which point mixing drives the plume relative humidity to the background humidity.
The history of the plume can be displayed as a “mixing line” (on the bottom-right plot in Fig. 2) on which the water partial pressure is plotted against plume temperature. The line starts in warm and moist conditions at the engine exit. The dilution of the plume, acting similarly on temperature and water mixing ratio, leads to a straight mixing line until the plume becomes supersaturated. Uptake of gaseous water onto aerosol then reduces the gaseous water partial pressure. Further mixing brings the plume to background state.
Some fraction of the fuel sulfur, which is released in the engine combustor, is converted to gaseous H2SO4 and quickly condenses. This results in both liquid sulfate aerosol particles but also coats already-existing particles (including engine-emitted black carbon particles). The bottom-left plot in Fig. 2 shows the coating fraction of black carbon particles over time. This fraction is the result of both adsorption (gas-phase H2SO4 condensing onto black carbon directly) and scavenging (collision with existing liquid droplets) as described in Kärcher (1998). In the absence of organic matter, the fractional coating is dominated by sulfuric acid. Adsorption of sulfur particles is initially the prevailing pathway to the formation of a black carbon coating. The coating fraction attributed to adsorption plateaus after ∼0.1 s as the gaseous molecular concentration of sulfuric acid becomes negligible. The remaining growth in the coating fraction is attributed to the scavenging of liquid sulfur aerosols onto black carbon particles.
As described in Sect. 2.2.3, organic matter can influence the black carbon fractional coating. Given the short timescales associated with formation of particulate organic matter, we assume that the black carbon particles are partially coated with condensable organic compounds in the first few milliseconds. As a sensitivity test, we vary the coating fraction attributable to organic species between 0 % and 25 %. The bottom-left plot of Fig. 2 shows the effect on total fractional coating. Our simplified treatment of organic species shows that the inclusion of organic compounds results in faster particle growth, affecting the transient regime in the first second after emission but does not have any effect on particle radius (upper-right plot) after approximately 1 s. Similarly, the gaseous chemical composition is unaffected by the condensation of organic compounds onto black carbon particles, even under supersaturated conditions.
3.1.2 Effects of fuel sulfur content
We next quantify the role of sulfur emissions on the plume gaseous composition and microphysical evolution. Ultrafine volatile particles are generated early on in the plume by gas-to-particle conversion, containing both sulfuric acid and organic compounds. As already discussed, these highly soluble species can condense onto the surface of black carbon particles, thus enhancing the coating fraction.
Figure 3 shows the effect of the fuel sulfur content on the black carbon fractional coverage and the partitioning between gaseous and liquid H2SO4. In this set of simulations, we vary the FSC between 50 and 5000 ppm. The results from our early-plume representation are in good agreement with the results from Kärcher (1998). The total sulfur concentration is the sum of gaseous H2SO4 and liquid sulfate and only decreases over time because of plume dilution.
In the low sulfur case, the black carbon particles are only coated on less than 5 % of their surface after 100 s. This value compares to ∼70 % in the high FSC case. Our median scenario, assuming a typical fuel sulfur content of 500 ppm by weight, reaches 35 %, with 30 % originating from the scavenging contribution. These median values are comparable with other studies of the early-plume microphysics (Wong and Miake-Lye, 2010; Kärcher, 1998).
As the plume cools down, H2SO4 undergoes conversion from gaseous phase to liquid. A large fraction of the emitted sulfur is consumed to form liquid particles and coat the aircraft-emitted particles over the first 100 ms after emissions (see Fig. 3).
Figure 3 indicates that increasing FSC enhances the particle coatings and the number of liquid plume particles. In addition, a smaller activated fraction on black carbon particles reduces the initial water condensation rate. However, when particles grow in diameter (of the order of ∼0.1 µm or more), the coating fraction becomes unimportant because of the much larger ice surface area. We observe no significant difference in the peak particle radius when varying the fuel sulfur content. This is in agreement with Busen and Schumann (1995), where no visual impact on contrail properties is detected after drastically reducing the FSC to 2 ppm.
Figure 4 describes the sensitivity of the sulfate aerosol distribution to the fuel sulfur content and its evolution throughout the first few minutes. In three experiments, we set the FSC to 50, 500, and 5000 ppm. Two regimes appear. In the low sulfur emission case, very few liquid particles are formed at the nucleation mode (∼0.5 nm). In this regime, coagulation is slow and the shape of the aerosol distribution is dictated by the dilution and the entrainment of background aerosols (whose mode is not represented in Fig. 4, given their larger size and smaller concentrations). In the high sulfur emission scenario, coagulation is more efficient and leads to the apparition of a second mode (∼3 nm). After 100 s, the two modes have approximately the same number of particles. At later times, the rate particle formation is reduced, thus promoting the coarser mode. At intermediate FSC values, the two modes still coexist but the larger mode contains more particles.
Similarly to liquid sulfate aerosols, particulate organic matter in aqueous aerosols is a primary contributor to the mass of ultrafine volatile particles. Previous studies have estimated its emission index at ∼20 mg kg, comparable to the sulfuric acid mass emission index, assuming an average fuel composition and conversion fraction from S(IV) to S(VI). Their similar emission indices and high solubility allow us to treat organic matter in an analogous way to sulfate aerosols and to draw conclusions that only differ quantitatively.
3.1.3 Role of black carbon emissions
In this section, we investigate the role of the black carbon emission index on the early-plume aerosol size distribution. We perform simulations in which the black carbon mass emission index is varied between 0.01 and 50 mg kg, to cover the potential range of current and future engine emission characteristics. We first focus on the impact of the emitted black carbon mass on its surface coating and then consider the effect on the particle radius over time, as both components could ice uptake and contrail lifetime.
Figure 5 indicates that we find no significant difference on the fractional coverage when varying the black carbon emissions by 3 orders of magnitude. In all cases, the contribution of sulfur adsorption to the black carbon area coverage is identical, and the contribution from liquid particle scavenging differs by a negligible amount.
Based on the results from Fig. 5, all cases studied in this section have similar coating fractions, independent of the black carbon emission index. However, Fig. 6 shows the in-plume relative humidity and particle radius when the black carbon emission index is varied. When the plume reaches saturation with respect to ice, the particle growth rate is the same regardless of the number of particles. In all simulations, the particles are competing for the same quantity of water. As a result, increasing the black carbon particle number density leads to smaller crystals, which in turn reduces the length of the supersaturated period for exhaust plumes in an initially subsaturated air mass. However, the same mechanism would be expected to result in longer contrail lifetimes for higher emissions indices if the air was initially saturated or supersaturated, due to the lower settling velocities of smaller particles.
Further reductions in the black carbon emission index could change the contrail formation pathway. The studies from Kärcher and Yu (2009) demonstrate that liquid plume particles (containing dissolved H2SO4 and organic compounds) could play a role in contrail ice formation at low black carbon number emissions and low temperatures. Ambient liquid particles are characterized by low number concentrations compared to an aircraft plume and thus cannot by themselves explain contrail formation. However, recent numerical simulations from Rojo et al. (2015) suggest that volatile particles could influence contrail formation, especially for alternative fuels in which the fuel sulfur content and black carbon emissions may be lower. Although we do not explicitly model the freezing of liquid plume particles, our simulations with increased black carbon number emissions provide some insight into the possible effect of organic and sulfate aerosols if they are capable of acting as ice nuclei.
3.2 Limitations of instant dilution
We first simulate the evolution of an aircraft plume as simulated using APCEMM. Figure 7 shows the time series of the ozone and NOx perturbations over the first 24 h after emission. The results as calculated under an instant-dilution assumption (single, well-mixed box) are also shown.
The chemical evolution of the plume can be split into three regimes, distinct from the dynamical regimes described in Sect. 2.1 (Song et al., 2003; Vinken et al., 2011). The first regime is characterized by very high NOx mixing ratios (>1 ppmv), causing ozone titration. In this period, typically lasting 10 min, high mixing ratios of nitric oxide (NO) rapidly deplete local ozone concentrations, resulting in a burst of NO2 production through Reaction (A1) (see Table 3). In this regime, HOx (= OH+HO2) production is suppressed by the lack of ozone (Reactions A5–A6).
As the plume dilutes and NOx mixing ratios fall below 1 ppmv, it enters the second regime. With little ozone remaining, HO2 reacts with the remaining NO (Reaction A4), producing OH and NO2 without depleting ozone. This leads to increased OH levels and enhanced ozone production. Meanwhile, photolysis of NO2 through Reaction (A2) results in the recovery of ozone, which had been depleted during the first regime. Between 1 and 2 h after emission, ozone has been restored to its background value. Reactions (A7) through (A10) lead to conversion of emitted NOx to nitrogen reservoir species.
A few hours after emission, the third regime begins, characterized by NOx mixing ratios below 1 ppbv. Reaction (A4) and reactions including organic peroxides (such as Reaction A12) cause increasing levels of ozone and additional conversion to reservoir species. Aircraft plumes, similarly to ship plumes, are characterized by a high NOx to volatile organic compound (VOC) ratio, therefore favoring termination reactions (e.g., Reaction A7) over catalytic ozone formation (Song et al., 2003).
R represents an organic compound. The RH notation is used to describe volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
Differences between the model outputs are dominated by the behavior during the first two regimes. Explicitly modeling the plume allows the initial ozone destruction to be captured because the highly concentrated plume is resolved. Although a recovery in ozone is later simulated once the plume diffuses, additional production that would have occurred during the early plume is prevented.
In the instant-dilution model, this ozone destruction and production cutoff is not captured. Because ozone is not locally depleted, the instant-dilution model instead simulates a prolonged period of net ozone production, as HOx concentrations remain close to background values. The instant-dilution approach, unlike APCEMM, bypasses the first two HOx-limited regimes and is therefore in a NOx-rich, HOx-rich environment, favoring daytime ozone production and conversion of NOx to reservoir species. Additionally, instant dilution of aircraft emissions results in shorter NOx lifetimes (see Appendix C for more details).
The net result is that, after 24 h, the instant-dilution approach estimates that the aircraft plume has produced ∼1.2 kg of ozone per kilometer flown, compared to ∼0.2 kg per kilometer estimated by APCEMM for a NOx emission index of 11.5 g kg. By this stage in the simulation, both models show similar chemical behavior, as the plume has become sufficiently dilute to be well represented by the instant-dilution model. However, the erroneous simulation of ozone production in the initial phase leads to a persistent and significant error in the net ozone production of the plume.
This behavior, and the discrepancy between APCEMM and an instant-dilution model, is strongly affected by local meteorology. Increased diffusion, or equivalently higher wind shear, dilutes the plume with a larger mass of air, minimizing ozone depletion. Therefore, total ozone production scales directly with mixing parameters. Table 4 shows the remaining NOx and total mass of produced ozone after 24 h as a function of the local diffusion coefficients. The results for instant dilution are shown in the last row. As diffusion rates increase and dilution becomes faster, the discrepancy between APCEMM and the instant-dilution model decreases towards zero. Errors in global simulation of aircraft impacts will therefore be maximized in regions with low diffusion and/or wind shear.
3.3 Influence of background conditions
The in-plume ozone perturbation (Δ[O3](t)) and the conversion efficiency of NOx to NOy are influenced by parameters such as the emission time and background conditions. We first investigate the influence of changes in background NOx. Figure 8 shows how the 24 h ozone emission conversion factor, , varies as a function of NOx background concentration and date of emission. Both simulations have been integrated over 24 h. All simulations are conducted after a 5 d spinup, and are simulated as occurring at 220 hPa altitude and 60∘ N.
The instant-dilution approach overestimates ozone production for any emission time, with emission conversion factors in the box model that are up to 3 times their respective values in the plume model. These discrepancies are greatest in summertime due to the larger ozone production term. The size of the ozone perturbation is sensitive to background concentrations of NOx in both models.
During summertime, increasing the background concentration of NOx from 100 to 200 pptv reduces the net (positive) ozone perturbation by 30 %–45 % in both models. During wintertime, the same change in background NOx has a negligible effect in the plume model, as shown in Fig. 8. However, the instant-dilution approach is still sensitive to this change. It produces a larger (more negative) ozone perturbation when the background NOx is increased during wintertime. This pattern is explained by a less efficient conversion of NOx to reservoir species at night. The transition between net positive and net negative ozone also changes as a function of the background NOx. At 50 pptv of background NOx, the plume model simulates net ozone production for 10 months, compared to 8 months in the instant-dilution model. At 200 pptv, net production is simulated for 6 and 5 months by the two models, respectively. This inconsistency in the magnitude and sign of the error between the two models means that the true impact of aviation emissions will be inconsistently modeled by an instant-dilution approach.
At a finer scale, we observe variations in emissions impacts depending on the time of day of the emission. Figure 9 shows contours of ozone and NOx emission conversion factors for different times of day over the course of a year. For most of the year, the total production of ozone is relatively insensitive to the exact time of day of the emission. The exception is during summertime, when emissions immediately before local sunset (the upper dotted line) cause almost twice as much ozone to be produced as an emission during late morning. This is discussed in more detail in Appendix C.
3.4 Influence of NOx emission index
In this section, we vary the NOx emission index while keeping other emissions unchanged. The total NOx emitted into the plume also affects chemical outcomes. Table 5 shows how a range of impact metrics are affected by changes in the NOx emission index. The overall ozone ECF decreases as the NOx emission index increases, falling from 3.2 for an EI of 8 g kg to 1.5 for an EI of 20 g kg. However, the product of these two factors – proportional to the total ozone present after 24 h – still increases monotonically with the emission index of NOx over the range of values considered.
Data obtained 24 h after emission and for emission at 08:00 LT on 16 June.
This implies that decreasing the NOx emission index provides non-linear benefits in terms of total ozone production. A single unit increase in the NOx emission index (expressed in g kg) leads to a reduction in of 0.08 mol mol−1 under high scenarios, but this increases to 0.2 mol mol−1 for the same absolute reduction in the NOx under low scenarios.
These results agree with the findings from Petry et al. (1998), Meijer (2001), and Vohralik et al. (2008). These simulations suggest that, relative to a plume-scale treatment of chemical processes, conventional instant-dilution approaches overestimate ozone production by up to a factor of 3, and overestimate conversion of nitrogen oxides to reservoir species. We also find that decreasing aircraft emissions of NOx emissions yields accelerating returns in terms of total in-plume ozone production but that these results are sensitive to background NOx concentrations.
3.5 Influence of pressure and latitude
The atmospheric response to aircraft emissions also varies as a function of the pressure and latitude of the emission. Although latitude is not a physical parameter of the model, it is equivalent to defining the amount of sunlight received, which affects photolysis rates and background conditions. We simulate pressures from 750 to 150 hPa and latitudes from 0 to 90∘ N. Temperature data are taken from monthly averaged MERRA-2 meteorological data for 2013. To capture variation of a single flight's emission conversion factors with geographic location and altitude, background conditions and photolysis rates are taken from GEOS-Chem. To also capture seasonal effects, simulations are carried out for emissions taking place on the winter and summer solstices as well as during the spring equinox, on 21 March. We perform simulations using both models. Results are presented in Fig. 10 in terms of ozone and NOx emission conversion factors. Isolines of the discrepancy between both models are plotted on Fig. 10 for O3 and NOx ( and ).
The results show a link between ozone production efficiency and latitude and pressure. Increasing pressure enhances the ozone emission conversion for the same amount of emitted NOx, given sufficient sunlight. The amount of sunlight drives ozone production, as little ozone is generated in the most northern latitudes during winter. At high flight altitudes or in cold regions, the daytime NOx-driven ozone production is of the order of magnitude of the ozone loss at dusk and the early titration effect. This cancellation leads to a small in-plume ozone perturbation of varying sign as shown previously (Vohralik et al., 2008).
The instant-dilution approach consistently overestimates the amount of ozone produced at cruise altitudes (∼150 to ∼240 hPa), as shown in Table 6. In absolute terms, the instant-dilution approach performs worst during summertime when ozone production is enhanced across the Northern Hemisphere and the discrepancy in the ozone emission conversion factor () is larger. The maximum ozone discrepancy (Table 6) reaches values around 5 in all seasons, corresponding to a relative error of approximately +200 %.
NOx conversion shows different sensitivities to location than the ozone ECF. As shown in the right panels of Fig. 10, the NOx ECF is positively correlated with ambient temperature but is insensitive to the amount of sunlight and season. As the temperature decreases with increasing altitude in the troposphere, the conversion of NOx to NOy is lowest at high altitude, going from an average value of 0.3 at 700 hPa to approximately 0.75 at 150 hPa. Greater conversion occurs in warmer air, around the Equator and the tropics. Furthermore, the instant-dilution approach underestimates the amount of remaining NOx at high altitudes but overestimates at lower levels. The crossover point varies significantly with season and latitude.
3.6 Contrail microphysical, optical, and chemical properties
All analysis thus far has concerned conditions that are subsaturated with respect to ice. The simulated plumes have therefore been made up only of gas-phase constituents and non-ice aerosol particles. However, a second discrepancy between instant-dilution models and real aircraft plumes is the lack of condensation trails in simulated aircraft exhaust, which can cause both climate and chemical impacts. This section assesses APCEMM's ability to simulate aircraft-induced condensation trails (“contrails”), quantifying how changes in background conditions affect the properties of the contrail. We then quantify the effect that these condensation trails have on the long-term atmospheric effects of aircraft emissions. This includes an investigation of differences in contrail lifetime and effects when forming in the stratosphere, as may result from supersonic flight.
In the following sections, we use similar background meteorological conditions to Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a). We simulate a 1 km thick supersaturated layer, below which there is a linear decrease in relative humidity at a rate of 12 % per hundred meters, to a background value of 50 %. The average supersaturation in the upper troposphere has been estimated to be around 15 % (Gierens et al., 1999), corresponding to a saturation of 115 % with respect to ice. Atmospheric shear is set to 0.002 s−1. The flight-level temperature is set to 217 K. A diurnal temperature variation with a 0.1 K amplitude is applied, corresponding to daily temperature fluctuations in the upper troposphere (Seidel et al., 2005). We also consider a range of contrail updraft velocities, from 0 to 10 cm s−1. This is based on previous studies that have shown that heating of contrail ice induces an upward convection motion with velocities in this range, such that the plume enters a colder environment (Unterstrasser and Gierens, 2010b; Unterstrasser et al., 2017b). This updraft can cause the contrail to advect out of the supersaturated layer. An intercomparison between APCEMM and Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a) is provided in Appendix D. As described in Appendix D2, the environment surrounding a contrail is characterized by local oscillations in the humidity field that arise from turbulent motion. This phenomenon is not explicitly in APCEMM and parameterization of these fluctuations is considered a future research priority.
3.6.1 Contrail simulations and the impact of relative humidity and initial contrail updraft velocity
We first simulate the formation and evolution of a contrail in aircraft exhaust under a variety of conditions to quantify the range of likely behaviors and verify behavior consistent with observations. For these purposes, we simulate an aircraft plume in locally supersaturated air, with flight-level relative humidities ranging from 104 % to 110 % and initial contrail updraft velocities from 0 to 10 cm s−1.
Figure 11 shows the temporal evolution of total contrail ice crystal number and mass for each combination of parameters, as well as the extinction-weighted effective diameter (Unterstrasser and Gierens, 2010a). In all cases, the contrail persists for at least 5 h but has sublimated after 10 h. These lifetimes are consistent with observations, in spite of the idealized meteorological conditions considered here (Minnis et al., 1998; Iwabuchi et al., 2012). Most ice crystals are lost through sublimation and in situ losses. In situ losses correspond to the sublimation of small crystals in favor of larger crystals when the relative humidity approaches 100 %. This phenomenon is attributed to Ostwald ripening through the Kelvin effect (Lewellen et al., 2014; Unterstrasser et al., 2017b). Losses through Brownian coagulation are negligible, as they account for less than 1 % of particle losses. As the contrail expands, the contrail core is dehydrated through gravitational sedimentation of the largest particles, leaving behind a population of smaller ice crystals with little ice mass but a significant surface area. The formation and settling of large ice crystals (with a radius greater than 30 µm) lead to early variations in contrail ice mass. This means that growth in contrail ice mass slows earlier than would be captured by reduced order models that consider only the mean settling velocity.
The contrail ice crystal number is reduced when the updraft velocity is set to 10 cm s−1. This is because the ice particles are advected out of the supersaturated region and thus sublimate quickly. The remaining crystals in the supersaturated region experience rapid growth, and their large settling velocity reduces the contrail lifetime. For updraft velocities of 0 and 5 cm s−1, the contrail remains in the supersaturated layer, thus increasing the total ice mass over a larger number of particles, resulting in an increased contrail lifetime.
The contrail ice mass peaks between 4 and 5 h after formation, with variations in timing affected by both the contrail updraft velocity and background relative humidity. In both cases, moister air result in greater overall water uptake and therefore larger ice particles. These larger particles then fall to drier altitudes and melt, reducing the available number of particles. Higher relative humidity also increase the extinction-weighted effective diameter for the same reason. This results in a trade-off between the “size” of the contrail, in terms of either the ice mass or effective diameter, and its lifetime, with more massive contrails having shorter lifetimes.
3.6.2 Influence of engine black carbon emission index on contrail properties
We next model how changes in black carbon emissions affect the properties of the contrail. We simulate an aircraft plume in which the black carbon mass emission indices are varied between 10 and 60 mg kg, compared to 10 to 14 mg kg estimated using the SN−CBC method for the GEnx engine. All other aircraft and engine emissions parameters are fixed for this sensitivity analysis. As a comparison, Stettler et al. (2013) estimate a fleet-wide average black carbon mass emission index of 28 mg kg, while in situ observations at cruise altitude have shown that different engines are estimated to have emission indices between 11 to 100 mg kg−1 fuel (Petzold et al., 1999). Each simulation assumes a flight-level temperature and relative humidity of 217 K and 110 %, respectively, and a post-vortex sinking updraft of 5 cm s−1.
Figure 12 shows the evolution of the total ice particle number, total ice mass, and extinction-weighted effective diameter for each emissions scenario. Considering first the total ice mass, two distinct regimes are visible. The first regime occurs over the first 3 h after formation. In this regime, all cases have identical ice masses. The contrail ice mass is controlled only by the ambient relative humidity, as all available water mass is taken up by whatever particles are available, with lower emission indices result in larger crystals.
After 3 h, the simulations with the lowest emission indices start to lose ice mass. This is because of the discrepancy in ice crystal radius. Since the same ice mass is taken up on a smaller number of particles, they become larger and fall more rapidly to warmer altitudes. Lower emission indices result in smaller particles, extending the lifetime of the contrail. As the largest crystals are removed, only a core of small crystals remains.
These changes in contrail ice also affect the optical thickness of the plume. We calculate optical thickness by integrating the extinction χ, as defined in Ebert and Curry (1992). Figure 13 shows the temporal evolution of the optical thickness, integrated over the vertical and horizontal (perpendicular to the flight path) axes. As seen previously, the ice water content is identical in the first few hours for all simulations, meaning that a scenario with a large particle number has a larger total crystal surface area. This means that reducing the black carbon emission index decreases both the optical depth of the contrail and its lifetime. This is quantified in Table 7, which quantifies the “predominant” optical depth as
following the formulation of Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a). Table 7 shows how this optical depth varies over time for each scenario. In all cases, the predominant optical depth increases with the black carbon emission index, with the relative difference between scenarios increasing over time until 4 h after emissions. After this time, the cases with the lowest black carbon emission indices have almost fully sublimated. Scaling the emitted black carbon by a factor 2 with respect to the baseline case (set to 20 mg kgfuel) increases the 2 h predominant optical depth by 14 %. Further enhancement of the black carbon emission index yields smaller increases in τpre, although we find no reversal in trend for EIBC up to 3 times the baseline value.
∗ Relative changes with respect to the baseline values corresponding to a black carbon mass emission index of 20 mg kgfuel.
Aggregating these results, we find that doubling the black carbon mass emission index from the baseline case increases the peak ice mass by approximately 24 % and delays the time at which the peak occurs by up to 1 h. This translates to a larger climate impact. Reducing the amount of released black carbon particles could instead cut down the contrail-cirrus radiative forcing; halving the black carbon emission index decreases the optical depth after 2 h by ∼15 %.
3.6.3 Influence of engine black carbon emissions on chemical composition
In addition to changing the optical properties of the contrail, black carbon emissions affect the chemical impact of the plume. Table 8 shows how the 24 h emissions conversion factors for ozone, NOx, and NOy reservoir species change between the scenarios described in Sect. 3.6.2. The comparison is here made with respect to a case where no contrail forms, thus yielding the contrail-related chemical perturbation.
Contrail-induced impacts on ozone production are small, with an overall difference of ∼10 % with respect to the pure gas-phase response. The NOy partitioning is affected to a greater extent. The ice crystal surface area in the plume provides a surface for rapid, heterogeneous conversion of N2O5 to HNO3. The descending, crystal-dense contrail therefore rapidly converts NOx into reservoir forms, with the overall rate and extent of conversion increasing with black carbon emissions. At a black carbon mass emission index of 20 mg kg, HNO3 concentrations are 170 % greater after 24 h than for the baseline case. We also find that concentrations of NOx, corresponding to the overall NOx “survival fraction”, are lower after 24 h with higher black carbon emissions due to the heterogeneous reactions on the surface of ice crystals.
Chemical species have an asymmetric profile across the contrail height. A greater aerosol surface area in the lower side of the plume leads to larger chemical rates through heterogeneous chemistry. The extent of the asymmetry depends on ice crystal microphysical parameters and therefore on meteorological conditions as well as aircraft parameters. Horizontally integrated chemical perturbations of O3, HNO3, and N2O5 in the upper troposphere can be found in Fig. S5 of the Supplement.
3.6.4 Effects of stratospheric contrails
We carry out an additional simulation to quantify how the radiative and chemical impact of contrails is different when forming in the stratosphere. Although unlikely due to the dry conditions of the stratosphere, any contrails that survive the initial formation stage would be likely to persist for significant periods due to the low mixing rates in this region of the atmosphere.
The relative humidity profile is kept identical. We find that the lower temperature lapse rate in the stratosphere leads to a smaller contrail ice mass, with optically thinner contrails. This is explained by lower temperatures in the lower part of the contrail core and in the fallstreak. As explained in Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a), a lower temperature reduces the effective crystal radius and optical thickness of the contrail. In the stratosphere, we find that contrails reach horizontal dimensions of 8 to 15 km compared to 5 to 10 km in the upper troposphere after 4 h.
The nitric acid emission conversion factors are also greater compared to the tropospheric case. In some cases, the HNO3 ECF reaches values above one as ambient, short-lived N2O5 is converted to long-lived HNO3. At a pressure of 100 hPa, a black carbon mass emission index of 10 mg kg leads to greater absolute contrail-induced impacts compared to typical subsonic altitudes. The relative changes are however smaller, corresponding to a 73 % and −69 % change in the HNO3 and N2O5 perturbations, respectively, compared to the baseline case. The same change in emission causes a decrease of the ozone perturbation per unit of NOx emitted by 21 % compared to 12 % for the tropospheric case. Figure S6 displays horizontally integrated chemical perturbations of O3, HNO3, and N2O5 under stratospheric background conditions.
Aircraft-induced stratospheric cirrus clouds are found to have shorter lifetimes and lead to a smaller optical thickness compared to tropospheric altitudes assuming similar relative humidity profiles. Heterogeneous chemistry on ice crystals gains greater importance at lower pressures and shifts the N2O5–HNO3 local equilibrium. Further work is needed to quantify how stratospheric contrails might differ from those that form in the troposphere.
Although our approach gives a significant improvement in terms of numerical fidelity compared to the instant-dilution approach, additional work is needed to account for additional physical phenomena. For example, APCEMM accounts for mixing with ambient air and the effect of wind shear on the plume. However, it does not capture the enhanced diffusion from the small-scale vortices generated by the wind shear. We also consider a highly simplified approach to simulate the aircraft-induced vortex dynamics and the vertical motion of the plume due to radiative heating of the contrail. APCEMM does not explicitly model turbulence in the vicinity of the contrail, which induces fluctuations in the relative humidity field of the order of ±5 % around saturation (Unterstrasser and Gierens, 2010a; Gierens and Bretl, 2009). Contrail regions with greater ice water content experience more heating, thus leading to a non-uniform adiabatic contrail uplift and a vertical stretching of the contrail. Additionally, we use a simplistic representation to model the role of organic species on the early-plume microphysics. Future work is planned to explicitly model these processes in APCEMM.
These results are also isolated to the 24 h period immediately following passage of an aircraft. In order to translate these results into an assessment of the net global impact of aviation, we aim to implement the results of the plume-scale processing of aircraft emissions into a global atmospheric chemistry transport model in a consistent manner with the chemistry and microphysical processes in place. However, doing so in a fashion that can be easily maintained will constitute a non-trivial software engineering challenge.
We develop a parameterized aircraft plume model to simulate chemistry in an aircraft wake. This study shows that neglecting the non-linear plume-scale processes leads to inaccuracies in the assessment of O3 perturbations and of the conversion of NOx to reservoir species.
We use APCEMM to quantify the 24 h atmospheric chemical response to aircraft emissions and how it differs from the results simulated under the instant-dilution approach typically used in global models. We also assess how this depends on ambient conditions, aircraft parameters, and fuel properties. Based on a parameter sweep for typical cruise conditions, we find that the instant-dilution assumption leads to greater ozone production compared to the plume model, with errors of up to ∼200 % at cruise altitude. This is due to plume-scale effects not resolved in the instant-dilution approach. In the plume model, the release of emissions into a small volume leads to O3 depletion (through NO titration) and a HOx-limited regime that last up to 5 h after emissions. The lack of HOx, which never occurs in the instant-dilution approach, causes enhanced ozone production and a reduced fraction of NOx remaining in the plume. We also quantify the role of wind shear and atmospheric diffusion.
Our approach also permits us to explicitly model the formation and effects of condensation trails. These affect the in-plume chemical response through heterogeneous reactions on the surface of ice crystals. Such plume-scale processes are not accounted for in almost all global-scale modeling approaches but are needed in order to fully understand the role of aircraft particulate emissions in upper tropospheric chemistry. We find that a 50 % reduction of the mass of emitted black carbon (assuming a baseline case of 20 mg kg) leads to a decrease of 16 % in the aircraft-attributable HNO3 perturbation, while ozone and nitrogen oxides increase by ∼3 % and 1.5 %, respectively. This is accompanied by a 15 % decrease in the 2 h optical depth of the contrail, such changes would not be captured in models that lack explicit plume modeling.
Previous studies assessing the impacts of aviation emissions have released emissions at the grid-scale level. We recommend that atmospheric models include a plume-scale treatment (or parameterization thereof) of aircraft emissions to compensate for these errors. Parameters should include meteorological conditions, local atmospheric composition, and flight properties, as well as engine and fuel characteristics. This is expected to significantly affect the estimated contribution of aircraft emissions to atmospheric NOx and ozone.
A1 Growth of ice particles during the early phase
As previously stated, the rate of change in the ice mass of a particle, mp, is given by
where is a function accounting for nucleus activation (Eq. A3), Cp is the ice crystal capacitance (equal to the particle radius rp for spherical nuclei), Dv,eff is the effective water vapor diffusion coefficient in air (Eq. A4), and is the water partial pressure.
The saturation vapor pressure of water is calculated as
where rp is the particle radius (in nm), rK is the Kelvin radius (set here to 2.3 nm), and is the saturation vapor pressure over a flat surface. The factor exp(rK∕rp) represents the effect of particle curvature (the Kelvin effect), increasing the apparent vapor pressure over a convex surface relative to a flat surface (Lewellen et al., 2014). is calculated as a function of temperature only (Pruppacher and Klett, 1998).
Growth is only permitted if particles are activated, meaning that they either already have an ice coating or in air that is locally supersaturated. This is characterized through the variable , as
where Ls is the latent heat of sublimation and κd the thermal conductivity of air. The function β accounts for the transition in uptake behavior between the gas kinetic (Kn≫1) to the diffusional regime (Kn→0) and is calculated as
with α being the deposition coefficient. For deposition of water molecules on ice particles, we take α=0.5, which is in agreement with laboratory and field studies from Haag et al. (2003). The mean free path of vapor molecules λv and the diffusion coefficient of vapor in air Dv are functions of the local temperature and pressure and are computed according to relations from Pruppacher and Klett (1998).
A2 Growth of liquid particles during the early phase
In the early-plume phase, liquid particles form as the plume undergoes rapid cooling. As stated previously, we use the parameterization from Vehkamäki et al. (2002) to compute nucleation rates, cluster size, and composition.
Throughout the plume lifetime, the growth of liquid particles is affected by coagulation, which dominates the early-plume phase because of the initially high aerosol particle concentrations. Coagulation is a volume-conserving process that decreases the aerosol number concentration.
Coagulation of newly formed aerosols and scavenging by black carbon and ice particles take place on different timescales. The coagulation timescale of particles of radius r1 can be evaluated from , where n2 and r2 are the number density and the radius of the scavenging particles. As shown in the Supplement, self-coagulation of liquid aerosols (r1=0.5–10 nm) occurs on a timescale of a few seconds to minutes, assuming a typical number density between 106 and 1010 particles cm−3. Similarly, scavenging by black carbon and ice particles happens over timescales that are of the same order of magnitude, assuming a radius of 50 nm (1 µm) for black carbon particles (for ice crystals, respectively) and a number density of 103 molecules cm−3. On the other hand, self-aggregation of black carbon particles and ice crystals occurs on timescales that are much longer, of the order of several hours.
The coagulation kernel represents Brownian diffusion, convective Brownian diffusion enhancement, sedimentation-induced aggregation, and turbulent inertial motion, as well as enhancement due to turbulent shear. The kernel is described by the following equations, taken from Jacobson (2005). We here consider a particle of size i coagulating with particles of size j.
The Brownian collision kernel is described by
where r is the particle radius, Dp the particle diffusion coefficient, δ the mean distance from the center of a sphere reached by particles leaving the sphere's surface and traveling a distance equal to the particle mean free path, and the thermal speed of a particle in air.
The convective Brownian diffusion enhancement kernel is defined by
where Re and Sc are the particle Reynolds and Schmidt numbers.
The sedimentation-induced aggregation kernel is described by
where Eagg is a collision efficiency.
The turbulent inertial motion and turbulent shear kernel are defined by
where εd is the rate of dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy, g the acceleration due to gravity, and νa the kinematic viscosity.
The total coagulation kernel is equal to the sum of each individual kernel:
We assume that the conversion of NOx to reservoir species is dictated by the daytime conversion pathway through the following reactions:
The chemical reaction rate can be written as
where HOx has been defined such that [HOx] = .
We assume that the concentration field at a fixed point can be expressed as the sum of spatially averaged quantity and the instantaneous fluctuation, such that
The chemical conversion rate of NOx can therefore be written as
The first term on the right-hand side leads to a net depletion. NO2 is an emitted species. Therefore, the NO2 fluctuation is positive in the core of the plume, while it is negative far away. HOx, however, gets depleted to form HNO3 and HO2NO2. Therefore, in the inner plume and outside of the core. Thus, the second term reduces NOx conversion and is proportional to the correlation of the fluctuations. If both fluctuations are negatively correlated, the depletion is reduced compared the case where the fields are uniform.
This explains why, for the same emission quantity, a small plume with large spatial fluctuations leads to a lower conversion compared to a large plume with smaller gradients.
In this section, we compare the results of APCEMM's microphysical module to existing data from numerical simulations. Although observational data are sparse, direct comparison to in situ measurements of both plume chemistry and ice would be a valuable future step.
We first compare the results of our simulation to Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a) for different case studies. In all the following cases, the same meteorological background conditions (1 km deep layer) and emission characteristics as Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a) are used. Using the same configuration, we then study the vertical distribution of the ice crystal number, surface and mass densities.
Figures D1 and D2 show the ice crystal concentration, ice mass concentration, extinction, and relative humidity profiles at three points in time according to the simulations from Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a) and APCEMM, respectively. We perform all comparisons using definitions from Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a). The spatial distributions of ice crystal number and mass densities at t=2000 s are in qualitative agreement, with a maximum horizontal discrepancy less than 500 m, although the small-scale discrepancies resolved by large eddy simulations are not reproduced by APCEMM. APCEMM also predicts a reduced vertical extent, likely because of a more uniform, smaller ice crystal size distribution. At later times, APCEMM fails to capture the greater horizontal extent of the contrail seen in the results from Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a). We believe that this is due to the faster initial settling that occurs in the large eddy simulations. This discrepancy is visible on the ice water content row in Figs. D2 and D1, where APCEMM predicts a horizontal extent of 6 and 12 km at t=8000 s and t=17 000 s, respectively, compared to 10 and 22 km according to the data from Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a). In spite of this, the integrated contrail ice mass and number both differ by less than 10 % at the three time instants.
The time evolution of the ice number density, mass density, and extinction shows similar trends between APCEMM and the high-fidelity simulations from Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a), but there are some significant differences. Overall, APCEMM predicts a longer contrail lifetime with greater ice mass, particle number, and extinction.
To fully understand the differences between these two models, a more detailed modeling study would be required. Qualitatively, we consider that there are a number of plausible explanations. One such explanation is that APCEMM does not represent the effect of turbulent motion, which causes fluctuations around supersaturation, as described in Gierens and Bretl (2009). Such local fluctuations in a supersaturated region would induce changes in the total ice mass and cause the local sublimation of ice crystals, which would tend to reduce the contrail lifetime.
The different numerical schemes used by the two models will also drive differences. We apply a simplified model for the movement of species in APCEMM, using a spectral method to simulate diffusion with spatially uniform coefficients, albeit time-varying and differing between the horizontal and vertical dimensions. APCEMM neglects 3-D effects, performing all calculations on a 2-D cross section of the exhaust. By comparison, the model used by Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a) performs 3-D large eddy simulations which will capture small- and large-scale dynamical features not resolved by APCEMM. They also use a different approach to represent ice microphysics, applying a two-moment scheme with an explicit correction for non-spherical ice particles.
Each of these factors will contribute to the differences in our comparison. Although APCEMM is designed to provide an intermediate-complexity approach which bridges the gap between, e.g., Gaussian plume approaches and large eddy simulations, it would be helpful to understand exactly why and where the results of APCEMM differ from those of both the higher- and lower-fidelity approaches. Future efforts to improve APCEMM's simulation of contrail dynamics would benefit from direct comparison to LES simulations in which different components of the simulation could be modified to identify the role of, e.g., turbulent fluctuations as opposed to differences in ice microphysics. It would also be useful to directly simulate a simulated 2-D flow field in APCEMM and thereby understand the degree of difference introduced by the simplified approach to transport.
D3 Contrail phases
This section aims to describe the different phases of the contrail as described by the simulations from APCEMM.
The peak particle number concentration decreases over time from an initial value of ∼10 cm−3. The fallstreak, particularly noticeable at t=17 000 s in Figs. D1 and D2, represents a significant fraction of the total ice mass, especially considering that it is characterized by a low number of ice crystals (∼20 times lower than the peak particle number). Moist air is entrained at the periphery of the contrail, leading to large spatial heterogeneities in the ice mass distribution. Given that the fallstreak is predominantly composed of large crystals, it can survive below the saturation depth until these crystals fully sublimate.
The extinction, as plotted on Fig. D2, represents the lidar-detectable region of the contrail (with a detection threshold of m−1). As pointed out in Unterstrasser and Gierens (2010a), non-negligible regions of the contrail cannot be detected through lidar measurements, as large ice crystals have a low extinction parameter.
The relative humidity profiles in Fig. D2 show that the core of the contrail is characterized with a uniform region, close to ice saturation. As the fallstreak sublimates under the saturation depth, it releases its water content at lower altitudes than the flight level, contributing to the dehydration of the upper troposphere/lower stratosphere.
Figure D3 displays the time evolution of horizontally integrated ice crystal densities assuming a 1 km deep saturation layer. In the first hour, the particle densities are approximately distributed symmetrically around the flight altitude, as settling has not contributed significantly. The ice mass continually increases until 5 h after emissions, leading to a vertical stretching of the contrail through gravitational settling of large particles. At that point, the ice mass density is concentrated at, or slightly below, the saturation depth (where the saturation reaches 100 %) and starts to decrease until the contrail has fully sublimated at 07:45 LT.
The colored dashed lines on Fig. D3 show the median altitude of the ice crystal number, surface and mass density distributions, respectively, at each time instant. Initially, all median values lie around the flight altitude. After ∼3 h, the median values start to “settle” at different speeds with the ice mass median altitude dropping the fastest, followed with the surface density and number density. This is due to the presence of a contrail core rich in small ice crystal particles (∼1 µm) and a fallstreak composed of larger and fewer nuclei contributing to a large fraction of the ice mass.
Figure S7 displays the same content as Fig. D3, assuming a supersaturated region extending between ±200 m. The same conclusions as in Fig. D3 can be drawn. After 6 h, the contrail has fully sublimated and it appears from Fig. S7 that the median altitudes converge towards the saturation depth.
The supplement related to this article is available online at: https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-5697-2020-supplement.
TMF implemented and ran the model, and wrote the manuscript. All authors were involved in study design, model validation and improvement, and manuscript review, editing, and finalization.
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
This work was supported by NASA grant no. NNX14AT22A. We would like to thank Dr. Simon Unterstrasser for providing data for comparison, as well as for the useful discussion regarding the simulation of the vortex sinking process.
This research has been supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Glenn Research Center (grant no. NNX14AT22A).
This paper was edited by Rolf Müller and reviewed by three anonymous referees.
Airbus: Global market forecast 2017–2036, available at: https://www.airbus.com/aircraft/market/global-market-forecast.html (last access: 10 April 2019), 2017. a
Beard, K. V. and Ochs III, H. T.: Collisions between small precipitation drops, Part II: Formulas for coalescence, temporary coalescence, and satellites, J. Atmos. Sci., 52, 3977–3996, 1995. a
Boeing: Commercial Market Outlook 2018-2037, available at: https://www.boeing.com/commercial/market/commercial-market-outlook (last access: 10 April 2019), 2017. a
Brasseur, G., Cox, R., Hauglustaine, D., Isaksen, I., Lelieveld, J., Lister, D., Sausen, R., Schumann, U., Wahner, A., and Wiesen, P.: European scientific assessment of the atmospheric effects of aircraft emissions, Atmos. Environ., 32, 2329–2418, 1998. a
Brasseur, G. P., Müller, J.-F., and Granier, C.: Atmospheric impact of NOx emissions by subsonic aircraft: A three-dimensional model study, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 101, 1423–1428, 1996. a
Busen, R. and Schumann, U.: Visible contrail formation from fuels with different sulfur contents, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 1357–1360, 1995. a
Cariolle, D., Caro, D., Paoli, R., Hauglustaine, D., Cuenot, B., Cozic, A., and Paugam, R.: Parameterization of plume chemistry into large-scale atmospheric models: Application to aircraft NOx emissions, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 114, D19302, https://doi.org/10.1029/2009JD011873, 2009. a
Cziczo, D., DeMott, P., Brooks, S., Prenni, A., Thomson, D., Baumgardner, D., Wilson, J., Kreidenweis, S., and Murphy, D.: Observations of organic species and atmospheric ice formation, Geophys. Res. Lett., 31, L12116, https://doi.org/10.1029/2004GL019822, 2004. a
Damian, V., Sandu, A., Damian, M., Potra, F., and Carmichael, G. R.: The kinetic preprocessor KPP-a software environment for solving chemical kinetics, Comput. Chem. Eng., 26, 1567–1579, 2002. a
DuBois, D. and Paynter, G. C.: “Fuel Flow Method2” for Estimating Aircraft Emissions, SAE Transactions, 1–14, 2006. a
Eastham, S. D. and Barrett, S. R.: Aviation-attributable ozone as a driver for changes in mortality related to air quality and skin cancer, Atmos. Environ., 144, 17–23, 2016. a
Eastham, S. D., Weisenstein, D. K., and Barrett, S. R.: Development and evaluation of the unified tropospheric–stratospheric chemistry extension (UCX) for the global chemistry-transport model GEOS-Chem, Atmos. Environ., 89, 52–63, 2014. a
Ebert, E. E. and Curry, J. A.: A parameterization of ice cloud optical properties for climate models, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 97, 3831–3836, 1992. a
Eyring, V., Stevenson, D. S., Lauer, A., Dentener, F. J., Butler, T., Collins, W. J., Ellingsen, K., Gauss, M., Hauglustaine, D. A., Isaksen, I. S. A., Lawrence, M. G., Richter, A., Rodriguez, J. M., Sanderson, M., Strahan, S. E., Sudo, K., Szopa, S., van Noije, T. P. C., and Wild, O.: Multi-model simulations of the impact of international shipping on Atmospheric Chemistry and Climate in 2000 and 2030, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 7, 757–780, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-7-757-2007, 2007. a
Forstall, W. and Shapiro, A. H.: Momentum and mass transfer in coaxial gas jets, J. Appl. Mechan.-Trans. ASME, 17, 399–408, 1950. a
Gierens, K. and Bretl, S.: Analytical treatment of ice sublimation and test of sublimation parameterisations in two–moment ice microphysics models, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 9, 7481–7490, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-9-7481-2009, 2009. a, b
Gierens, K., Schumann, U., Helten, M., Smit, H., and Marenco, A.: A distribution law for relative humidity in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere derived from three years of MOZAIC measurements, in: Annales Geophysicae, Vol. 17, 1218–1226, Springer, 1999. a
Goodman, J., Pueschel, R., Jensen, E., Verma, S., Ferry, G., Howard, S. D., Kinne, S., and Baumgardner, D.: Shape and size of contrails ice particles, Geophys. Res. Lett., 25, 1327–1330, 1998. a
Gottlieb, D. and Orszag, S. A.: Numerical analysis of spectral methods: theory and applications, Vol. 26, Siam, 1977. a
Gupta, K., Rehman, A., and Sarviya, R.: Bio-fuels for the gas turbine: A review, Renew. Sustain. Ener. Rev., 14, 2946–2955, 2010. a
Haag, W., Kärcher, B., Ström, J., Minikin, A., Lohmann, U., Ovarlez, J., and Stohl, A.: Freezing thresholds and cirrus cloud formation mechanisms inferred from in situ measurements of relative humidity, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 3, 1791–1806, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-3-1791-2003, 2003. a
Hidalgo, H.: The Stratosphere, Perturbed by Propulsion Effluents, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, D.C., Appendix E, Summary-CIAP Mon.3,DOT-TST-75-50, December, 1974. a
Huszar, P., Teyssèdre, H., Michou, M., Voldoire, A., Olivié, D. J. L., Saint-Martin, D., Cariolle, D., Senesi, S., Salas Y Melia, D., Alias, A., Karcher, F., Ricaud, P., and Halenka, T.: Modeling the present and future impact of aviation on climate: an AOGCM approach with online coupled chemistry, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 13, 10027–10048, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-13-10027-2013, 2013. a
Iwabuchi, H., Yang, P., Liou, K., and Minnis, P.: Physical and optical properties of persistent contrails: Climatology and interpretation, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 117, D06215, https://doi.org/10.1029/2011JD017020, 2012. a
Jacobson, M. Z.: Development and application of a new air pollution modeling system–II. Aerosol module structure and design, Atmos. Environ., 31, 131–144, 1997. a
Jacobson, M. Z.: Development of mixed-phase clouds from multiple aerosol size distributions and the effect of the clouds on aerosol removal, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 108, 4245, https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JD002691, 2003. a, b
Jacobson, M. Z., Turco, R. P., Jensen, E. J., and Toon, O. B.: Modeling coagulation among particles of different composition and size, Atmos. Environ., 28, 1327–1338, 1994. a
Jaecker-Voirol, A. and Mirabel, P.: Heteromolecular nucleation in the sulfuric acid-water system, Atmos. Environ., 23, 2053–2057, 1989. a
Jensen, E., Toon, O., Pueschel, R., Goodman, J., Sachse, G., Anderson, B., Chan, K., Baumgardner, D., and Miake-Lye, R.: Ice crystal nucleation and growth in contrails forming at low ambient temperatures, Geophys. Res. Lett., 25, 1371–1374, 1998a. a
Jensen, E. J., Ackerman, A. S., Stevens, D. E., Toon, O. B., and Minnis, P.: Spreading and growth of contrails in a sheared environment, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 103, 31557–31567, https://doi.org/10.1029/98JD02594, 1998. a, b, c, d
Jung, J. G., Pandis, S. N., and Adams, P. J.: Evaluation of nucleation theories in a sulfur-rich environment, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 42, 495–504, 2008. a
Kärcher, B.: Aviation-produced aerosols and contrails, Surv. Geophys., 20, 113–167, 1999. a
Kärcher, B.: Formation and radiative forcing of contrail cirrus, Nat. Commun., 9, 1–17, 2018. a
Kärcher, B., Busen, R., Petzold, A., Schröder, F., Schumann, U., and Jensen, E.: Physicochemistry of aircraft-generated liquid aerosols, soot, and ice particles: 2. Comparison with observations and sensitivity studies, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 103, 17129–17147, 1998. a
Kärcher, B., Turco, R., Yu, F., Danilin, M., Weisenstein, D., Miake-Lye, R., and Busen, R.: A unified model for ultrafine aircraft particle emissions, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 105, 29379–29386, 2000. a, b
Kraabøl, A. G., Konopka, P., Stordal, F., and Schlager, H.: Modelling chemistry in aircraft plumes 1: comparison with observations and evaluation of a layered approach, Atmos. Environ., 34, 3939–3950, 2000. a, b
Lee, J. J., Lukachko, S. P., Waitz, I. A., and Schafer, A.: Historical and future trends in aircraft performance, cost, and emissions, Annu. Rev. Energ. Environ., 26, 167–200, 2001. a
Lukachko, S., Waitz, I., Miake-Lye, R., Brown, R., and Anderson, M.: Production of sulfate aerosol precursors in the turbine and exhaust nozzle of an aircraft engine, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 103, 16159–16174, 1998. a
Mazraati, M.: World aviation fuel demand outlook, OPEC energy review, 34, 42–72, 2010. a
Meijer, E., Velthoven, P., Thompson, A., Pfister, L., Schlager, H., Schulte, P., and Kelder, H.: Model calculations of the impact of NOx from air traffic, lightning, and surface emissions, compared with measurements, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 105, 3833–3850, 2000. a
Minnis, P., Young, D. F., Garber, D. P., Nguyen, L., Smith, W. L., and Palikonda, R.: Transformation of contrails into cirrus during SUCCESS, Geophys. Res. Lett., 25, 1157–1160, 1998. a
Murray, B. J., Wilson, T. W., Dobbie, S., Cui, Z., Al-Jumur, S. M., Möhler, O., Schnaiter, M., Wagner, R., Benz, S., Niemand, M., Saathoff, H., Ebert, V., Wagner, S., and Kärcher, B.: Heterogeneous nucleation of ice particles on glassy aerosols under cirrus conditions, Nat. Geosci., 3, 233–237, 2010. a
Naiman, A., Lele, S., and Jacobson, M.: Large eddy simulations of contrail development: Sensitivity to initial and ambient conditions over first twenty minutes, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 116, D21208, https://doi.org/10.1029/2011JD015806, 2011. a
Napari, I., Noppel, M., Vehkamäki, H., and Kulmala, M.: Parametrization of ternary nucleation rates for H2SO4-NH3-H2O vapors, J. Geophys. Res., 107, 4381, https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JD002132, 2002. a
Paoli, R., Vancassel, X., Garnier, F., and Mirabel, P.: Large-eddy simulation of a turbulent jet and a vortex sheet interaction: particle formation and evolution in the near field of an aircraft wake, Meteorol. Z., 17, 131–144, 2008. a
Paoli, R., Thouron, O., Cariolle, D., García, M., and Escobar, J.: Three-dimensional large-eddy simulations of the early phase of contrail-to-cirrus transition: effects of atmospheric turbulence and radiative transfer, Meteorol. Z. (Berlin), 26, 597–620, https://doi.org/10.1127/metz/2017/0764, 2017. a
Paugam, R., Paoli, R., and Cariolle, D.: Influence of vortex dynamics and atmospheric turbulence on the early evolution of a contrail, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 3933–3952, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-10-3933-2010, 2010. a
Penner, J. E., Lister, D. H., Griggs, D. J., Dokken, D. J., and McFarland, M.: Aviation and the global atmosphere, – A special report of IPCC working groups I and III (Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA: Cambridge University Press), 1999. a
Petry, H., Hendricks, J., Möllhoff, M., Lippert, E., Meier, A., Ebel, A., and Sausen, R.: Chemical conversion of subsonic aircraft emissions in the dispersing plume: Calculation of effective emission indices, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 103, 5759–5772, 1998. a, b
Petzold, A., Döpelheuer, A., Brock, C., and Schröder, F.: In situ observations and model calculations of black carbon emission by aircraft at cruise altitude, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 104, 22171–22181, 1999. a, b, c
Picot, J., Paoli, R., Thouron, O., and Cariolle, D.: Large-eddy simulation of contrail evolution in the vortex phase and its interaction with atmospheric turbulence, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 7369–7389, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-7369-2015, 2015. a, b, c
Schröder, F., Kärcher, B., Duroure, C., Ström, J., Petzold, A., Gayet, J.-F., Strauss, B., Wendling, P., and Borrmann, S.: On the transition of contrails into cirrus clouds, J. Atmos. Sci., 57, 464–480, 2000. a
Schumann, U.: The impact of nitrogen oxides emissions from aircraft upon the atmosphere at flight altitudes–results from the AERONOX project, Atmos. Environ., 31, 1723–1733, 1997. a
Schumann, U., Konopka, P., Baumann, R., Busen, R., Gerz, T., Schlager, H., Schulte, P., and Volkert, H.: Estimate of diffusion parameters of aircraft exhaust plumes near the tropopause from nitric oxide and turbulence measurements, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 100, 14147–14162, 1995. a, b, c
Schumann, U., Schlager, H., Arnold, F., Ovarlez, J., Kelder, H., Hov, Ø., Hayman, G., Isaksen, I., Staehelin, J., and Whitefield, P. D.: Pollution from aircraft emissions in the North Atlantic flight corridor: Overview on the POLINAT projects, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 105, 3605–3631, 2000. a
Schumann, U., Arnold, F., Busen, R., Curtius, J., Kärcher, B., Kiendler, A., Petzold, A., Schlager, H., Schröder, F., and Wohlfrom, K.-H.: Influence of fuel sulfur on the composition of aircraft exhaust plumes: The experiments SULFUR 1–7, J. Geophys. Res., 107, 4247, https://doi.org/10.1029/2001JD000813, 2002. a
Song, C. H., Chen, G., Hanna, S. R., Crawford, J., and Davis, D. D.: Dispersion and chemical evolution of ship plumes in the marine boundary layer: Investigation of O3∕NOy/HOx chemistry, J. Geophys. Res., 108, 4143, https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JD002216, 2003. a, b
Speth, R. L., Rojo, C., Malina, R., and Barrett, S. R.: Black carbon emissions reductions from combustion of alternative jet fuels, Atmos. Environ., 105, 37–42, 2015. a
Tabazadeh, A., Jensen, E. J., and Toon, O. B.: A model description for cirrus cloud nucleation from homogeneous freezing of sulfate aerosols, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 102, 23845–23850, 1997. a
Tang, M. J., Cox, R. A., and Kalberer, M.: Compilation and evaluation of gas phase diffusion coefficients of reactive trace gases in the atmosphere: volume 1. Inorganic compounds, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 9233–9247, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-14-9233-2014, 2014. a
Thompson, A. M., Friedl, R. R., and Wesoky, H. L.: Atmospheric e§ects of aviation. First Report of theSubsonic, NASA Reference Publication 1385, 1996. a
Toon, O. B. and Miake-Lye, R. C.: Subsonic aircraft: Contrail and cloud effects special study (SUCCESS), Geophys. Res. Lett., 25, 1109–1112, 1998. a
Tremmel, H., Schlager, H., Konopka, P., Schulte, P., Arnold, F., Klemm, M., and Droste-Franke, B.: Observations and model calculations of jet aircraft exhaust products at cruise altitude and inferred initial OH emissions, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 103, 10803–10816, 1998. a
Tremmel, H. G. and Schumann, U.: Model simulations of fuel sulfur conversion efficiencies in an aircraft engine: Dependence on reaction rate constants and initial species mixing ratios, Aero. Sci. Technol., 3, 417–430, 1999. a
Unterstrasser, S. and Gierens, K.: Numerical simulations of contrail-to-cirrus transition – Part 1: An extensive parametric study, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 2017–2036, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-10-2017-2010, 2010a. a, b, c, d, e, f, g, h, i, j, k, l, m, n, o, p, q, r, s
Unterstrasser, S. and Gierens, K.: Numerical simulations of contrail-to-cirrus transition – Part 2: Impact of initial ice crystal number, radiation, stratification, secondary nucleation and layer depth, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 2037–2051, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-10-2037-2010, 2010b. a
Unterstrasser, S., Gierens, K., Sölch, I., and Wirth, M.: Numerical simulations of homogeneously nucleated natural cirrus and contrail-cirrus. Part 2: Interaction on local scale, Meteorol. Z., 26, 643–661, https://doi.org/10.1127/metz/2016/0780, 2017a. a
Unterstrasser, S., Gierens, K., Sölch, I., and Lainer, M.: Numerical simulations of homogeneously nucleated natural cirrus and contrail-cirrus. Part 1: How different are they?, Meteorol. Z., 26, 621–642, 2017b. a, b
Vehkamäki, H., Kulmala, M., Napari, I., Lehtinen, K. E., Timmreck, C., Noppel, M., and Laaksonen, A.: An improved parameterization for sulfuric acid–water nucleation rates for tropospheric and stratospheric conditions, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 107, 4622, https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JD002184, 2002. a, b, c
Vinken, G. C. M., Boersma, K. F., Jacob, D. J., and Meijer, E. W.: Accounting for non-linear chemistry of ship plumes in the GEOS-Chem global chemistry transport model, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 11707–11722, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-11-11707-2011, 2011. a
Wong, H.-W. and Miake-Lye, R. C.: Parametric studies of contrail ice particle formation in jet regime using microphysical parcel modeling, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 3261–3272, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-10-3261-2010, 2010. a, b, c, d
Yu, F., Turco, R. P., and Kärcher, B.: The possible role of organics in the formation and evolution of ultrafine aircraft particles, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 104, 4079–4087, 1999. a