Tracking separate contributions of diesel and gasoline vehicles to roadside PM2.5 through online monitoring of volatile organic compounds and PM2.5 organic and elemental carbon: a 6-year study in Hong Kong
- 1Division of Environment & Sustainability, Hong Kong University of Science & Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR, China
- 2Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department, 47/F, Revenue Tower, 5 Gloucester Road, Wan Chai, Hong Kong SAR, China
- 3Department of Chemistry, Hong Kong University of Science & Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR, China
Correspondence: Jian Zhen Yu (email@example.com)
Vehicular emissions contribute a significant portion to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) air pollution in urban areas. Knowledge of the relative contribution of gasoline- versus diesel-powered vehicles is highly relevant for policymaking, and yet there is a lack of an effective observation-based method to determine this quantity, especially for its robust tracking over a period of years. In this work, we present an approach to track separate contributions of gasoline and diesel vehicles through the positive matrix factorization (PMF) analysis of online monitoring data measurable by relatively inexpensive analytical instruments. They are PM2.5 organic and elemental carbon (OC and EC), C2–C9 volatile organic compounds (VOCs) (e.g., pentanes, benzene, xylenes, etc.), and nitrogen oxide concentrations. The method was applied to monitoring data spanning more than 6 years between 2011 and 2017 in a roadside environment in Hong Kong. We found that diesel vehicles accounted for ∼70 %–90 % of the vehicular PM2.5 (PMvehicle) over the years and the remainder from gasoline vehicles. The diesel PMvehicle during truck- and bus-dominated periods showed declining trends simultaneous with control efforts targeted at diesel commercial vehicles and franchised buses in the intervening period. The combined PMvehicle from diesel and gasoline vehicles by PMF agrees well with an independent estimate by the EC-tracer method, both confirming PMvehicle contributed significantly to the PM2.5 in this urban environment (∼4–8 µg m−3, representing 30 %–60 % in summer and 10 %–20 % in winter). Our work shows that the long-term monitoring of roadside VOCs and PM2.5 OC and EC is effective for tracking gaseous and PM pollutants from different vehicle categories. This work also demonstrates the value of an evidence-based approach in support of effective control policy formulation.
Vehicular emissions (VEs) are among the major sources of air pollution in the urban environment. Major constituents in VE include nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and fine particulate matter (PM2.5). Two primary components in vehicular PM2.5 (PMvehicle) are elemental carbon (EC) and organic matter (OM) (Kleeman et al., 2000; Chow et al., 2011). Growing evidence has shown that exposure to VE affects human health (Peters et al., 2004; Beelen et al., 2008; Benbrahim-Tallaa et al., 2012; Rice et al., 2015). With an increasing number of the global population residing in urban areas, VEs have become the major target for source control in many parts of the world. But uncertainty over the relative importance of diesel and gasoline vehicles to PMvehicle often poses a challenge in effective policymaking (Gertler, 2005).
The chemical mass balance (CMB) model and positive matrix factorization (PMF) model are two prevalent receptor models for quantifying contributing sources to PM2.5, including VE. However, their capability to resolve separate contributions of diesel and gasoline vehicles is often severely constrained when relying on chemical constituents residing in the PM (particulate matter) fraction alone. In the CMB model, EC and certain organic compounds (e.g., hopanes, benzo[ghi]perylene and coronene) have been specifically used as tracers for deriving diesel and gasoline PMvehicle contributions, respectively (Schauer et al., 1996; Subramanian et al., 2006; Chow et al., 2007). However, the contributions of the two are often subjected to large uncertainty due to the substantial variability in source profiles and oxidation degradation of organic tracers (Subramanian et al., 2006; Weitkamp et al., 2008). On the other hand, PMF analysis of PM compositions often yields one overall VE factor due to the lack of tracers specific to individual VE types, and the difficulty is compounded by the often similar temporal patterns of traffic activity among different vehicle types (Dallmann et al., 2014; Lee et al., 2015; Wang et al., 2017). Some other chemical characteristics, such as subfractions of organic carbon (OC) and EC obtained from thermal analysis and metals (e.g., Mn and Fe), have been used in PMF analyses to differentiate between diesel and gasoline contributions (Kelly et al., 2013). These characteristics, however, are relatively less specific and thus they are often not applicable to typical urban areas where a complex mix of contributing sources exists.
In Hong Kong (HK), the PMvehicle contribution from diesel vehicles has reduced significantly over the last 2 decades, resulting from a series of ambitious control efforts. The success has been verified by results from an ad hoc roadside study and a study comparing the emissions in a local tunnel between 2003 and 2015 (Lee et al., 2017; Wang et al., 2018). Most HK studies in the past only reported overall PMvehicle contributions due to the lack of separate local source profiles for diesel and gasoline vehicles and constraints in the PMF model posed by a lack of vehicle type specific tracers (Li et al., 2012; Huang et al., 2014; Cheng et al., 2015; Sun et al., 2016). Some studies achieved the separation either by using nonlocal source profiles in the CMB model or by coupling vehicle-type-specific traffic data collected in a short period with aerosol-mass-spectrometry-based PMF (Zheng et al., 2006; Lee et al., 2017). The lack of a robust means to differentiate between diesel and gasoline contributions to PMvehicle calls for the need to develop a more effective source apportionment strategy, especially considering the long-term need in monitoring their impact on air quality.
In VOC source apportionment studies, certain VOC species have been used to track the contributions of specific vehicle types, such as propane and butanes for vehicles fueled by liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and pentanes and toluene for gasoline vehicles (Lyu et al., 2016; Yao et al., 2019). These gaseous species, however, are rarely considered for deriving vehicle-type-specific PMvehicle. Lambe et al. (2009) added a few VOC species into their 2 h resolution organic-tracer-based PMF to explicitly apportion black carbon in Pittsburgh, USA, to diesel and gasoline vehicles. Thornhill et al. (2010) also used PMF with real-time gaseous species (including VOCs) and PM2.5 concentration data captured by a suite of mobile equipment to quantify PM2.5 contributions from diesel and gasoline vehicles in Mexico City. Our group reported a limited exploration of the combined use of hourly VOC and PM2.5 OC and EC data in PMF analyses to estimate the total PMvehicle in a roadside environment in HK (Huang et al., 2014). Here, we present a detailed investigation on the feasibility of such an approach for separating PMvehicle contributions by diesel and gasoline vehicles using a comprehensive dataset covering 6 years between 2011 and 2017.
The objective of this work is to establish an approach to obtain vehicle-type-specific PMvehicle through the integration of online routine monitoring data, such as NOx and hourly VOC and OC–EC measurement data, into the PMF analysis. The study features a 6-year-long monitoring (2011–2017) of a roadside environment in HK. We evaluate this new method by comparing the total PMvehicle derived from an independent EC-tracer method developed previously, and for the first time we report the long-term trends in PMvehicle for diesel and gasoline vehicles in HK (Huang et al., 2014; Wong et al., 2019). Several policies targeted at diesel vehicles fell within the timeline of the study period, providing a valuable opportunity to examine their effectiveness. The methodology presented in this study for instrument deployment, data collection and analysis could help air quality management authorities to obtain measurement-based evidence from the routine monitoring dataset for evaluating the effectiveness of control policies targeting VEs.
2.1 Roadside measurements
The study window spans over a 6-year period from May 2011 to August 2017. Sampling was conducted at Mong Kok Air Quality Monitoring Station (MK AQMS), which is a roadside site in the Air Quality Monitoring Network operated by the HK Environmental Protection Department (HKEPD). The station is located at the junction of two trunk roads with an annual average daily traffic count of ∼ 45 000 (Transport Department, 2018). Previous vehicle counting exercises showed that private cars fueled by gasoline, goods vehicles and buses fueled by diesel, and taxis running on LPG made up 32 %, 22 %, 16 % and 29 %, respectively, of the vehicle fleet in the sampling area (Lee et al., 2017). In addition to the busy traffic, there are small shops, restaurants, and tall residential and commercial buildings in the immediate vicinity of the station. A previous study has shown that on-road vehicles are the most important source of submicron carbonaceous aerosols at the site, followed by cooking activities (Lee et al., 2015).
A semicontinuous OC–EC field analyzer system (RT-4, Sunset Laboratory, OR, USA) was operated to obtain hourly OC–EC concentration data of PM2.5. Details for the on-site operation, instrument conditions and quality control work during the entire sampling period are provided in the Supplement. Hourly concentration data for PM2.5, C2–C9 VOCs and trace gases including NOx and CO measured at the MK AQMS were provided by HKEPD. Details of the monitoring equipment can be found in HKEPD's annual air quality report (Environmental Protection Department, 2018). In particular, the VOCs were measured with a GC955 series 611/811 VOC analyzer (Syntech Spectras, The Netherlands), which quantifies 30 species, including 11 C2–C8 alkanes, 9 C2–C5 alkenes, 1 C2 alkyne and 9 C6–C9 single-ring aromatics.
2.2 Data treatment
To avoid biased interpretation of the relationships between the measured species, we excluded hourly samples with one or more missing species from the subsequent data analyses. Sampling days with a data cover rate (i.e., number of valid data points∕total number of hours during the study period) <75 % were also excluded to maximize the representativeness of the concentration data of a sampling day. The trends presented throughout this study are constructed from the monthly averages. Only months with a data cover rate >33 % are considered. The monthly data cover rates are summarized in Fig. S1 in the Supplement.
2.3 Estimation of vehicular PM2.5 by positive matrix factorization
In this work, vehicular contributions to PM2.5 are quantified by PMF analysis using the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) PMF 5.0 software (Norris et al., 2014). PMF is a receptor model that solves the chemical mass balance of a speciated sample data matrix by decomposing it into factor profiles and factor contributions with nonnegative constraints, with the objective being to minimize the objective function Q (Paatero and Tapper, 1994; Paatero, 1997). The Q value represents the uncertainty weighted deviation between observed and modeled species concentrations.
Hourly concentrations of OC, EC, NOx, CO and 12 selected VOC species from the entire monitoring period are considered in the PMF model for a single analysis. The VOCs, which were consistently detected above the detection limit (>80 % in each calendar year), include ethene, ethane, propane, propene, i-butane, n-butane, i-pentane, n-pentane, benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and m- and p-xylene. Some examples of the excluded VOCs are butadiene, n-hexane and n-heptane. Preliminary PMF analysis showed that including these species had no advantage in identifying more sources. Meanwhile, the considerable fraction of data below the detection limit for these species would affect the quality of the PMF solutions. Details regarding other modeling inputs are provided in the Supplement.
Vehicle-related VOCs in the roadside environment are freshly emitted and thus should be mostly conserved, rendering them suitable for receptor modeling. However, for the non-roadside environment, the effect of photochemical reactions should first be examined and the correction of VOC input data should be made when needed to avoid bias in source apportioning (He et al., 2019).
PMvehicle for individual vehicle types are calculated as the sum of OM and EC in the corresponding factor profiles, considering that it is primarily composed of OM and EC. OM is estimated to be OC multiplied by a factor of 1.2 based on organic aerosol mass spectra measured for both diesel and gasoline VEs (Dallmann et al., 2014; Lee et al., 2015).
We note that cooking emissions, a known OC source in MK, is not considered in the current PMF analysis as the measurement of relevant tracer compounds was not supported with the instrumentation deployed in this study. We therefore relax the modeling of OC (i.e., allow the modeled OC to have a relatively larger deviation from measurement) by tripling its uncertainty. This approach lets the apportioning of OC have a larger degree of freedom, which in effect allows the model to only capture the OC that is associated with the fitting species whilst leaving the unrelated fraction as unapportioned OC. A sensitivity test showed that a further doubling of the OC uncertainty would not cause a discernible impact on the PMF solutions.
The robustness of the PMF solutions is examined through executing the displacement (DISP) and Fpeak (strength values of −5 and 5) functions. In the bootstrap (BS) analysis, the input dataset was split into three groups of equal sample size for execution because of the limited computing capability of the software (total sample size = 24 586). Nevertheless, this practice allows us to assess the model uncertainty associated with using different subsets of samples, which will be discussed in the result section.
2.4 Estimation of vehicular PM2.5 by the EC-tracer method
To evaluate the PMF estimation, an EC-tracer method specifically designed for estimating PMvehicle contributions in roadside environments is applied. Details regarding the principle and application of this method are documented in our previous work, and a brief account is given here (Huang et al., 2014; Wong et al., 2019). In this method, VE is assumed to have a characteristic OC-to-EC ratio – (OC ∕ EC)vehicle – and to be responsible for all ambient EC. The latter represents a reasonable approximation given that the EC at MK AQMS was dominated by traffic exhaust over the entire study period, which will be discussed further in Sect. 3.1.2. With these assumptions, OCvehicle can be estimated as the product of the ambient EC concentration and the (OC ∕ EC)vehicle, while PMvehicle can be estimated using the approach similar to that introduced in Sect. 2.3 (i.e., ).
The (OC ∕ EC)vehicle is determined using the minimum OC ∕ EC ratio approach, in which the ambient OC in a certain lowest percentage range by the OC ∕ EC ratio is regressed on ambient EC, and the slope obtained represents the target ratio (Lim and Turpin, 2002). This minimum ambient OC ∕ EC ratio is perceived to be of minimal contributions from secondary formation and non-vehicular primary sources, which typically have a higher OC ∕ EC ratio than VEs (e.g., cooking emissions and biomass burning). In this study, the optimal Deming regression evaluated previously is applied to the lowest 5 % data by the OC ∕ EC ratio on a monthly basis (Huang et al., 2014). The analysis is performed using the Igor-based (WaveMetrics, Inc. Lake Oswego, OR, USA) computer program developed by Wu and Yu (2018).
3.1 Ambient trends
3.1.1 OC trends
The monthly OC concentration showed a decreasing trend over the 6-year period from May 2011 to August 2017, as shown in Fig. 1a. A consistent seasonal cycle with fall–winter (mid-September to mid-March of the next year) high, summer (mid-May to mid-September) low and spring (mid-March to mid-May) in between is observed over the years. The study-wide OC in the three seasonal periods were 6.9±3.4, 3.9±2.6 and 5.9±2.8 µg C m−3, respectively (Fig. S2). The main cause for the seasonal variations of OC is related to the geographical location of HK, which is in the coastal area facing the South China Sea to the south and mainland China to the north. During the fall/winter monsoon season, the prevailing northeasterly wind transports pollutants from the continental area to HK, while in summer the prevailing southerly wind carries clean air masses from the sea (Louie et al., 2005; Hagler et al., 2006; Huang et al., 2014). Another plausible reason for the elevated OC observed in wintertime is the enhanced partitioning of semivolatile organic compounds (SVOCs) into the particle phase due to lower temperature and higher organic aerosol loading. Previous studies at the same monitoring site show that VE-related organic aerosol (derived from PMF analysis of organic aerosol mass spectra) decreases by 40 % in summer relative to spring despite consistency in traffic flow volume, which points to a sizable influence of the gas-particle partitioning of SVOCs (Lee et al., 2017).
It is noted that the winter OC had a larger improvement than summer OC over the monitoring period, as shown in the season-specific trend plot in Fig. S3. The average OC concentration in winter dropped by 6.4 µg C m−3 (from 10.7 µg C m−3 in 2011 to 4.3 µg C m−3 in 2017), while the decrease in summer was 2.3 µg C m−3 (from 5.1 to 2.8 µg C m−3) during the same period. Such a difference demonstrates the benefit on local air quality of collaborative efforts in reducing regional air pollution over the years.
3.1.2 EC trends
The 6-year trend of EC concentration is plotted in Fig. 1b, which shows a different temporal characteristic compared to OC. A main feature of the EC trend is the lack of seasonality throughout the years. The study-wide seasonal concentrations remained at ∼5 µg C m−3 for all seasons (Fig. S2). The absence of seasonal variation indicates local emissions dominated EC at this roadside site, and the impact of regional sources on EC, as opposed to OC, was limited. We previously demonstrated that EC at MK AQMS was mainly influenced by vehicular traffic by showing similarities in their diurnal and weekday–holiday variation patterns (Huang et al., 2014). Such correlations persisted over the years, as shown in Fig. S4. Specifically, during workdays, EC concentration increased 4-fold from its minimum during the small hours to ∼4–8 µg C m−3 during daytime. The corresponding increase was 2-fold for the holiday period, consistent with the reduced traffic flow volume. These multiple lines of evidence indicate that EC at the site was mainly affected by local VE sources and less impacted by regional sources.
In the first 3 years, the monthly EC concentrations fluctuated in the 5–6 µg C m−3 range. Starting from mid-2014, they declined significantly to the level of ∼3 µg C m−3 toward the end of the measurement period. A similar variation trend was also observed for NOx (Fig. 1c), which is mainly generated by on-road diesel vehicles in the roadside environment. Notably, these decreasing trends coincided with the launch of a program to phase out pre-Euro IV diesel commercial vehicles in March 2014 in HK. The results here imply diesel vehicles were the major EC contributor at the sampling site.
3.1.3 Carbonaceous aerosols and PM2.5 trends
The relative contributions of carbonaceous aerosols to PM2.5 at MK AQMS over the study window are shown in Fig. 1d. OM was approximated as OC ×1.4 for typical urban aerosols with primary and secondary origins. The PM2.5 concentration is overlaid on the same plot. As shown in the figure, PM2.5 concentration displayed a seasonal variation (winter high and summer low) similar to that of OC over the years, which was the result of the combined effect of regional air pollutant transport and meteorological conditions, as discussed in Sect. 3.1.1. In the middle of the year with warmer weather and lower PM2.5 mass (∼20 µ g m−3), EC showed an elevated relative contribution of ∼30 %, and EC and OM had comparable contributions to PM2.5. The opposite was observed in the colder season with higher PM2.5 mass (30–60 µg m−3). EC only made up ∼15 % of the aerosol mass, while OM accounted for ∼30 %. About two-thirds of the PM2.5 in these periods was composed of non-carbonaceous materials. Based on HKEPD's chemical speciation results for 24 h filter samples, these materials mainly consist of secondary inorganics (sulfate, nitrate and ammonium), followed by crustal material and trace elements (Yu and Zhang, 2018). The secondary inorganic components have long been attributed to regional air pollution. The persistently large contributions from these components over the years indicate that controlling PM2.5, including its gaseous precursors (SO2, NOx and NH3), on a regional scale is still important for reducing the overall PM2.5 at this roadside location.
3.1.4 The n-butane and i-pentane trends
Figure 1 also shows multiyear trends in VOCs that are associated with specific vehicle types (LPG and gasoline). At MK AQMS, n-butane has been used to track LPG-fueled vehicles (Lyu et al., 2016; Yao et al., 2019). As shown in Fig. 1e, the n-butane level did not show obvious monthly variations over the years, supporting the theory that this species was predominantly emitted by local LPG vehicles (box-plot statistics of the monthly concentration are shown in Fig. S5). It remained at the ∼10–15 ppbv level in mid-2011–mid-2013, dropped precipitously to ∼7 ppbv in the second half of 2013 and was followed by a steadily declining trend until the end of the study period. Yao et al. (2019) reported similar trend characteristics for the same site with a more continuous dataset (September 2012–April 2017). The drop in the second half of 2013 was a response to a catalytic converter replacement scheme for LPG-fueled vehicles implemented by the government (Lyu et al., 2016).
Similar to n-butane, i-pentane was also dominated by a local source as reflected in the absence of seasonality over the years (Fig. 1f). This gasoline exhaust/evaporation tracer remained fairly stable at the ∼1 ppbv level over the entire study period. Such an invariability is in line with a previous study showing that the VOC contributions from gasoline-powered vehicles in the same study area were relatively stable over the similar period (Yao et al., 2019).
3.2 (OC ∕ EC)vehicle for EC-tracer method
(OC ∕ EC)vehicle determined using summer month data (June, July and August) is very similar over the years and does not exhibit an obvious trend over the years, as shown in Fig. 2a. The ratios range from 0.30 to 0.47, with R2 between 0.56 and 0.96 (sample size n=18–33). Figure 2b plots the frequency of occurrence of the lowest 5 % of OC ∕ EC ratios in the 24 h of a day for the summer months. It shows that the lowest ratios occurred most frequently near the morning rush hour (07:00–10:00 LT; all times are in Hong Kong local time) with minimal contributions from other primary sources (e.g., cooking emissions), supporting the theory that these ratios were dominated by VEs. The ratios were a factor of 2–3 higher in winter (Fig. S6), likely as a result of enhanced OC contributions from aged air masses and biomass burning from regional transport, as discussed in Sect. 3.1.1. Thus, these values were likely biased high. Another complicating factor is that the reduction in ambient temperature and elevation in organic aerosol concentration in the colder season would favor the partitioning of SVOCs into the particle phase, thereby inflating the (OC ∕ EC)vehicle (Robinson et al., 2007). We did not account for this effect in this study. Instead, the summer values were adopted for deriving the (OC ∕ EC)vehicle, and this ratio is considered a lower estimate for colder season samples. Given that similar (OC ∕ EC)vehicle values were obtained in the summer months over the years, the mean value of 0.35 (standard deviation =0.05) is considered to be the best estimate of (OC ∕ EC)vehicle for subsequent analyses.
3.3 Vehicular contributions from the PMF analysis
3.3.1 Source identification
Among various PMF solutions, the five-factor solution is the most interpretable for source identification and quantification. The drop in Qtrue∕Qexpected value, which reflects the improvement in modeled species concentrations against measurements, is more significant when the factor number is increased by one from three to five compared to from five to eight (Fig. S7). This implies that five factors are sufficient and suitable for explaining the variations of input species data. The contributing sources are identified by studying the presence of marker species and temporal variations in normalized contributions, as shown in Fig. 3.
Three vehicular factors are identified, corresponding to the vehicle types observed near the sampling site. The first factor represents diesel exhaust as it contains the majority of NOx and EC, which are largely attributed to diesel vehicles. The low OC ∕ EC ratio of 0.5 and diurnal profile, in line with the traffic flow of diesel vehicles next to the site, further confirm its source identity.
The second factor is associated with gasoline vehicles due to the dominant presence of i- and n-pentane. This factor also has a diurnal profile consistent with gasoline vehicle flow near the site, with the evening peak occurring 2 hours later than that of diesel vehicles. The i- and n-pentane could be emitted through fuel evaporation and as unburned gasoline in tailpipe exhaust, whereas the carbonaceous particulates with an OC ∕ EC ratio of 2.5 and CO signal tailpipe exhaust.
The contribution of LPG-fueled vehicles is identified in the third factor by propane and i- and n-butane originating mainly from fuel evaporation. Its diurnal variation pattern is consistent with the activity pattern (busy in the small hours) of local taxis running on LPG (Yu et al., 2016). Note that this vehicle type has a negligible contribution to PM in agreement with the highly volatile nature of LPG.
The fourth factor contains a notable amount of toluene, ethylbenzene, and m- and p-xylene that commonly exist in consumer and industrial products as solvents or in gasoline as additives (Bolden et al., 2015). Previous studies attributed this factor to solvent usage (Lyu et al., 2016; Yao et al., 2019). However, upon closer examination of its diurnal pattern, we found that this factor shows regular peaks around 11:00 and 17:00. Given that the MK AQMS is surrounded by 16 around-the-clock gas stations within 1.5 km (Fig. S8) and that the peak business hours of some of these stations show a similar diurnal variation pattern (based on popular times information from Google Maps; Fig. S8), we classify this factor as a fuel-filling process instead of solvent usage. The VOC characteristic ratios (e.g., ethylbenzene ∕ m- and p-xylene ratio) of this profile are also in reasonable agreement with the local fuel composition. Details of the comparison are given in Table S3.
The last factor has abundant chemically stable ethane and benzene. Particulates in this factor are also enriched substantially in OC (OC ∕ EC ratio ∼9). In contrast to the three vehicle-related factors, the absence of diurnal variation and the presence of winter high and summer low contributions were noted (Fig. 3). These characteristics collectively indicate that this factor is an aged air mass.
3.3.2 Model evaluation
Modeling uncertainty estimation from DISP, Fpeak and BS (grouped samples) shows that the solutions are rotationally and statistically robust, with details provided in the Supplement. In particular, the factor profiles from the three grouped PMF analyses are very similar, as shown in Fig. S9. The (OC ∕ EC)vehicle ratios for diesel vehicles are 0.5 in all grouped runs, while those for gasoline vehicles are 1.8–2.2, implying that the chemical characteristics of PMvehicle of the two remained similar over the study period. The PMF (base run) solution is also evaluated with the modeling performance of the fitting species, which are summarized in Table S4. Most gaseous species are well reproduced (R2=0.73–0.95) except ethene and ethane (R2=0.32–0.40) due to their higher measurement uncertainties. Modeled EC is also consistent with the measurement (R2=0.90), but OC in comparison shows a larger discrepancy (R2=0.64).
To unveil the cause of the OC discrepancy, we compare the modeled and measured OC concentrations on a diurnal basis. The result is presented in Fig. 4 using a box diagram. The plot reveals that the discrepancy mainly occurred during 12:00–14:00 and 18:00–21:00. More specifically, the modeled OC was considerably lower than the measurement during these two periods. This feature remained across all seasons, as depicted in Fig. S10. Previous studies have attributed the two organic peaks during these two mealtime periods to cooking emissions (Lee et al., 2015; Sun et al., 2016). As mentioned in Sect. 2.3, we were unable to account for this source in the PMF analyses due to the lack of suitable tracer species for cooking emissions. Nevertheless, Fig. 4 shows that the modeled and measured OC had good agreement during the non-mealtime hours (i.e., 0:00–11:00 and 15:00–17:00). This indicates that the aged air mass factor and VE factors resolved by the PMF were able to explain the non-cooking OC, lending support to the PMF-derived OCvehicle. It should be noted that although PMF without down-weighting OC could bring the modeled OC into better agreement with the measurements, the resolved factor profiles were less consistent among the three grouped PMF analyses, which caused discontinuity in factor contributions between different periods. The improved interpretability of the PMF results indicates that down-weighting OC is necessary in our situation.
3.3.3 PMF-derived OCvehicle trends
The separate diesel and gasoline OCvehicle concentrations over the entire study period are shown in Fig. 5a. A decreasing trend in the overall OCvehicle started to emerge in mid-2014 which was driven by the reduction in diesel OCvehicle. Between mid-2011 and mid-2014, diesel OCvehicle hovered at the ∼2 µg C m−3 level. It then started decreasing until 2017, at which point the concentration had dropped by half. Gasoline contribution, on the other hand, remained at the ∼1 µg C m−3 level over the entire study period. As a result of the different pace of reductions, gasoline OCvehicle had grown in relative importance over the years, as shown in Fig. 5d. In the first 3 years, gasoline vehicles were a smaller contributor compared to diesel vehicles, accounting for ∼30 % of the OCvehicle, but afterwards their contribution became comparable to that of diesel vehicles, growing to 40 %–50 %. Diesel and gasoline OCvehicle derived from the grouped PMF analyses and the associated uncertainties derived from the 5th and 95th percentiles of the BS results are plotted in Fig. S11a, while the results obtained from the base run are also shown as solid lines in the graph. It appears that the division of samples into three time periods does not exert discernible influence on the results, though the gasoline OCvehicle occasionally deviated from the base result noticeably in the first time period. But in general, OCvehicle from the two vehicle categories has converged over the whole study period.
The overall OCvehicle derived from the EC-tracer method is plotted in Fig. 5a for comparison. It appears that this independent method can only account for the diesel fraction of PMF-derived OCvehicle. A plausible reason is that the (OC ∕ EC)vehicle determined through the minimum OC ∕ EC ratio approach (0.35) is biased toward diesel exhaust with a low OC ∕ EC ratio (0.47 from PMF). The comparison here suggests the OCvehicle derived from the EC-tracer method reflects the diesel influence better.
The relative contribution of total OCvehicle to ambient OC exhibited a large seasonal dependence (Fig. S12a). In winter months when the ambient OC concentration was high, VE made up 30 %–40 % of OC. The percentage share increased sharply to 70 %–100 % in summer months when ambient OC was low. However, it should be noted that the PMF-modeled OC occasionally exceeded the measurement, and the exceedance increased with decreasing ambient OC levels (Fig. S13). This could be attributed to the uncertainties arising from PMF modeling and the measurement of low levels of OC, and thus the relative importance in summer months is likely overestimated.
3.3.4 PMF-derived ECvehicle trends
Trends in vehicular EC (ECvehicle) were very similar to those for OCvehicle, as shown in Fig. 5b. Different from OCvehicle, the ECvehicle derived from the PMF and EC-tracer method, which is essentially the ambient EC, agree well with each other. This is because PMF attributed the majority of the ambient EC to VE sources, more than 70 %, as shown in Fig. S12b. For this reason, the change in ECvehicle was very similar to that of ambient EC and thus is not repeated here. A key finding is that diesel vehicles dominated the ECvehicle over the entire study period, constituting more than 80 % of ECvehicle, as shown in Fig. 5e. Such dominance remains valid after the consideration of PMF modeling uncertainties (Fig. S11b). The above findings emphasize that the reduction in EC over the years was mostly attributed to the control of diesel vehicles, and this vehicle category should deserve closer attention for further EC abatement.
3.3.5 PMF-derived PMvehicle trends
The positive impact on air quality of vehicle control policies, if any, is more obvious if EC and OM from VEs are considered together (i.e., PMvehicle). The monthly average PMvehicle by vehicle category is given in Fig. 5c. As of mid-2014, PMvehicle fluctuated slightly around the 8 µg m−3 level, followed by a considerable reduction to the ∼4 µg m−3 level in the beginning of 2017. This amount of reduction represents one-fifth of typical PM2.5 concentrations at MK AQMS during summer (∼20 µg m−3). As noted in Fig. 5c, the reduction in PMvehicle was mainly driven by diesel vehicles, which were also the dominant PMvehicle contributors over the whole study period, as shown in Fig. 5f. Another finding from Fig. 5f is that the relative importance of gasoline vehicles has only grown slightly from ∼20 % before mid-2014 to ∼30 % afterwards despite the drastic decrease in diesel PMvehicle. After considering the PMF modeling uncertainties, as depicted in Fig. S11c, it is still clear that diesel vehicles have dominated PMvehicle at MK AQMS over the entire study period, and this vehicle class should remain the focal point for the further control of PMvehicle.
PMvehicle estimated by the EC-tracer method is also compared with the PMF method in Fig. 5c. As shown, the disparity between the two approaches has narrowed considerably compared to OCvehicle. The improvement mainly involves the consideration of EC, which is similarly perceived as a tracer for VEs in the two estimation methods. The similarity between the PMvehicle obtained from the two methods lends support to our PMF model as producing reasonable estimates for separate diesel and gasoline PMvehicle contributions. Furthermore, the consistent results obtained from both methods highlight that PMvehicle was an important contributor to the PM2.5 at MK AQMS with noticeable seasonal variations similar to those of OCvehicle, as shown in Fig. S12c. Based on the PMF results, during summer and under the dominance of local sources, VEs were responsible for ∼30 %–60 % of ambient PM2.5 during the study period. When PM2.5 concentrations increased in winter due to regional influence, VE contributions dropped to roughly 10 %–20 %.
3.4 Policy evaluation
Tackling tailpipe emissions from diesel commercial vehicles (DCVs) and franchised buses is a long-term need in HK (Environment Bureau, 2013). A 3-day detailed traffic counting exercise was conducted by the government at the MK AQMS in May 2013. The details were reported in Lee et al. (2017). From that we are able to identify a truck-dominated period around midday (11:00–13:00) during which the number of trucks (i.e., DCVs) is a factor of 2–3 higher than that of buses (∼100 vs. ∼40 vehicles h−1), as well as a midnight period (22:00–0:00) with the bus count being 3 times higher than the count of trucks (∼60 vs. ∼20 vehicles h−1). Hence, the annual trends in diesel PMvehicle extracted from these two periods could provide an indication of how diesel PMvehicle was impacted by different policies. The results are presented in Fig. 6. Also shown in the figure is a background condition represented by the small hours (02:00–04:00) when diesel vehicle numbers reach the minimum (∼10 vehicles h−1). A clear declining trend in diesel PMvehicle is noted for both vehicle-dominated periods, with both trends approaching the levels in the background period.
For the truck-dominated trend, the PMvehicle levels started to drop after March 2014, which marks the commencement of the program to phase out pre-Euro IV DCVs implemented by the government. This program aimed at progressively replacing all pre-Euro IV DCVs (∼ 82 000) in HK by the end of 2019 (Environment Bureau, 2013). The diesel PMvehicle concentrations in the pre-DCV program period and the start of 2017 were respectively ∼9 and ∼5 µg m−3, representing almost a 50 % reduction. The reduction also appeared to respond reasonably with the progress of the program shown in Fig. 6. Prior to this DCV program, another scheme that replaced ∼ 7400 Euro II DCVs was launched during July 2010–June 2013. That program, however, did not produce an obvious impact on diesel PMvehicle possibly because of the smaller scale of the implementation compared to the more recent DCV program.
The declining trend in diesel PMvehicle during the bus-dominated period could be attributed to a host of control measures for franchised buses. In the intervening years, local franchised bus companies have been continuously scrapping and replacing old model buses with newer model buses that comply with higher Euro standards (Environment Bureau, 2013). At the level of transportation management, the government has been pursuing reductions in bus trips in congested corridors through a rationalization of the bus routes. Setting up low emission zones in densely populated spots including the MK area, where only cleaner-model franchised buses are allowed, might also contribute to the decrease in bus-related PMvehicle contribution (Environment Bureau, 2013).
We present a holistic analysis on the long-term monitoring data of hourly PM2.5 OC and EC, vehicle-specific VOCs (e.g., n-butane and i-pentane), and NOx concentrations in an urban roadside environment in HK. The dataset covers a 6-year period from May 2011 to August 2017. Both OC and EC concentrations were observed to decrease notably over the entire study period plausibly due to the efficient control of pollution sources in both regional and local contexts. By integrating OC, EC and VOC (e.g., n-butane, i-pentane, benzene and xylene) datasets into PMF analysis, we successfully differentiate between PMvehicle contributions from diesel and gasoline vehicles, and for the first time report their individual long-term trends. The overall PMvehicle is also estimated by the EC-tracer method, which shows good agreement with that from the PMF analysis, supporting the PMvehicle estimate from the PMF. Our work identifies diesel vehicles as the dominant vehicle type in contributing PMvehicle (∼70 %–80 %) over the entire study period. Thus, further VE control efforts for mitigating roadside PMvehicle in HK should focus on diesel vehicles. The technique developed in this work could be extrapolated to other roadside environments with mixed vehicular contributions, considering that both continuous OC and EC analyzers and online VOC instruments are increasingly incorporated in governments' air quality monitoring programs. We note that the OCvehicle estimated by this approach serves as a lower limit for the vehicle-contributed OC since the fitting species considered here are all tracers for primary emissions. The primary emissions from on-road vehicles also have great potential to form secondary organic aerosols (Gentner et al., 2017), and this secondary PM derived from vehicles is not captured in PMvehicle estimates by our method. Future work should attempt to quantify this missing fraction of vehicular PM2.5 for more insightful policy implications.
The data presented in this article are available from the authors upon request. Please contact Jian Zhen Yu (firstname.lastname@example.org).
The supplement related to this article is available online at: https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-9871-2020-supplement.
JZY, XHHH and YKW designed the field experiments with assistance from PKKL, ALCY and DHLC. YKW and XHHH carried out the EC–OC measurements. YKW performed the data analysis and prepared the paper with contributions from all coauthors.
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
The content of this paper does not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the HKSAR government, nor does the mention of trade names or commercial products constitute an endorsement or recommendation of their use.
We thank HKEPD for the provision of the hourly VOC dataset.
This research has been supported by the Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department (project nos. AS10-336, 12-00255 and 14-05593) and the Hong Kong Research Grants Council (grant no. 16305418).
This paper was edited by Willy Maenhaut and reviewed by two anonymous referees.
Beelen, R., Hoek, G., van den Brandt, P. A, Goldbohm, R. A., Fischer, P., Schouten, L. J., Jerrett, M., Hughes, E., Armstrong, B., and Brunekreef, B.: Long-term effects of traffic-related air pollution on mortality in a Dutch cohort (NLCS-AIR Study), Environ. Health Persp., 116, 196–202, 2008.
Benbrahim-Tallaa, L., Baan, R. A., Grosse, Y., Lauby-Secretan, B., El Ghissassi, F., Bouvard, V., Guha, N., Loomis, D., and Straif, K.: Carcinogenicity of diesel-engine and gasoline-engine exhausts and some nitroarenes, Lancet Oncol., 13, 663–664, 2012.
Bolden, A. L., Kwiatkowski, C. F., and Colborn, T.: New look at BTEX: Are ambient levels a problem?, Environ. Sci. Technol., 49, 5261–5276, 2015.
Cheng, Y., Lee, S. C., Gu, Z. L., Ho, K. F., Zhang, Y. W., Huang, Y., Chow, J. C., Watson, J. G., Cao, J. J., and Zhang, R. J.: PM2.5 and PM10−2.5 chemical composition and source apportionment near a Hong Kong roadway, Particuology, 18, 96–104, 2015.
Chow, J. C., Watson, J. G., Lowenthal, D. H., Chen, L. W. A., Zielinska, B., Mazzoleni, L. R., and Magliano, K. L.: Evaluation of organic markers for chemical mass balance source apportionment at the Fresno Supersite, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 7, 1741–1754, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-7-1741-2007, 2007.
Chow, J. C., Watson, J. G., Lowenthal, D. H., Chen, L. W. A., and Motallebi, N.: PM2.5 source profiles for black and organic carbon emission inventories, Atmos. Environ., 45, 5407–5414, 2011.
Dallmann, T. R., Onasch, T. B., Kirchstetter, T. W., Worton, D. R., Fortner, E. C., Herndon, S. C., Wood, E. C., Franklin, J. P., Worsnop, D. R., Goldstein, A. H., and Harley, R. A.: Characterization of particulate matter emissions from on-road gasoline and diesel vehicles using a soot particle aerosol mass spectrometer, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 7585–7599, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-14-7585-2014, 2014.
Environment Bureau: A Clean Air Plan for Hong Kong, available at: https://www.enb.gov.hk/en/files/New_Air_Plan_en.pdf (last access: 24 August 2020), 2013.
Environmental Protection Department: Air quality in Hong Kong 2017, The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Hong Kong, 2018.
Gentner, D. R., Jathar, S. H., Gordon, T. D., Bahreini, R., Day, D. A., El Haddad, I., Hayes, P. L., Pieber, S. M., Platt, S. M., de Gouw, J., Goldstein, A. H., Harley, R. A., Jimenez, J. L., Prévôt, A. S. H., and Robinson, A. L.: Review of urban secondary organic aerosol formation from gasoline and diesel motor vehicle emissions, Environ. Sci. Technol., 51, 1074–1093, 2017.
Gertler, A. W.: Diesel vs. gasoline emissions: Does PM from diesel or gasoline vehicles dominate in the US?, Atmos. Environ., 39, 2349–2355, 2005.
Hagler, G. S. W., Bergin, M. H., Salmon, L. G., Yu, J. Z., Wan, E. C. H., Zheng, M., Zeng, L. M., Kiang, C. S., Zhang, Y. H., Lau, A. K. H., and Schauer, J. J.: Source areas and chemical composition of fine particulate matter in the Pearl River Delta region of China, Atmos. Environ., 40, 3802–3815, 2006.
He, Z., Wang, X., Ling, Z., Zhao, J., Guo, H., Shao, M., and Wang, Z.: Contributions of different anthropogenic volatile organic compound sources to ozone formation at a receptor site in the Pearl River Delta region and its policy implications, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 19, 8801–8816, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-19-8801-2019, 2019.
Huang, X. H. H., Bian, Q. J., Louie, P. K. K., and Yu, J. Z.: Contributions of vehicular carbonaceous aerosols to PM2.5 in a roadside environment in Hong Kong, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 9279–9293, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-14-9279-2014, 2014.
Kelly, K. E., Kotchenruther, R., Kuprov, R., and Silcox, G. D.: Receptor model source attributions for Utah's Salt Lake City airshed and the impacts of wintertime secondary ammonium nitrate and ammonium chloride aerosol, J. Air Waste Manage., 63, 575–590, 2013.
Kleeman, M. J., Schauer, J. J., and Cass, G. R.: Size and composition distribution of fine particulate matter emitted from motor vehicles, Environ. Sci. Technol., 34, 1132–1142, 2000.
Lambe, A. T., Logue, J. M., Kreisberg, N. M., Hering, S. V., Worton, D. R., Goldstein, A. H., Donahue, N. M., and Robinson, A. L.: Apportioning black carbon to sources using highly time-resolved ambient measurements of organic molecular markers in Pittsburgh, Atmos. Environ., 43, 3941–3950, 2009.
Lee, B. P., Li, Y. J., Yu, J. Z., Louie, P. K. K., and Chan, C. K.: Characteristics of submicron particulate matter at the urban roadside in downtown Hong Kong – Overview of 4 months of continuous high-resolution aerosol mass spectrometer measurements, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 120, 7040–7058, 2015.
Lee, B. P., Louie, P. K. K., Luk, C., and Chan, C. K.: Evaluation of traffic exhaust contributions to ambient carbonaceous submicron particulate matter in an urban roadside environment in Hong Kong, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 17, 15121–15135, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-17-15121-2017, 2017.
Li, Y. C., Yu, J. Z., Ho, S. S. H., Yuan, Z. B., Lau, A. K. H., and Huang, X. F.: Chemical characteristics of PM2.5 and organic aerosol source analysis during cold front episodes in Hong Kong, China, Atmos. Res., 118, 41–51, 2012.
Lim, H. J. and Turpin, B. J.: Origins of primary and secondary organic aerosol in Atlanta: results of time resolved measurements during the Atlanta supersite experiment, Environ. Sci. Technol., 36, 4489–4496, 2002.
Louie, P. K. K., Watson, J. G., Chow, J. C., Chan, A., Sin, D. W. M., and Lau, A. K. H.: Seasonal characteristics and regional transport of PM2.5 in Hong Kong, Atmos. Environ., 39, 1695–1710, 2005.
Lyu, X., Guo, H., Simpson, I. J., Meinardi, S., Louie, P. K. K., Ling, Z., Wang, Y., Liu, M., Luk, C. W. Y., Wang, N., and Blake, D. R.: Effectiveness of replacing catalytic converters in LPG-fueled vehicles in Hong Kong, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 6609–6626, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-16-6609-2016, 2016.
Norris, G., Duvall, R., Brown, S., and Bai, S.: EPA Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) 5.0 Fundamentals and User Guide, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., USA, 2014.
Paatero, P.: Least squares formulation of robust non-negative factor analysis, Chemometr. Intell. Lab., 37, 23–35, 1997.
Paatero, P. and Tapper, U.: Positive matrix factorization: A non-negative factor model with optimal utilization of error estimates of data values, Environmetrics, 5, 111–126, 1994.
Peters, A., von Klot, S., Heier, M., Trentinaglia, I., Hörmann, A., Wichmann, H. E., and Löwel, H.: Exposure to traffic and the onset of myocardial infarction, New Engl. J. Med., 351, 1721–1730, 2004.
Rice, M. B., Ljungman, P. L., Wilker, E. H., Dorans, K. S., Gold, D. R., Schwartz, J., Koutrakis, P., Washko, G. R., O'Connor, G. T., and Mittleman, M. A.: Long-term exposure to traffic emissions and fine particulate matter and lung function decline in the Framingham Heart Study, Am. J. Resp. Crit. Care., 191, 656–664, 2015.
Robinson, A. L., Donahue, N. M., Shrivastava, M. K., Weitkamp, E. A., Sage, A. M., Grieshop, A. P., Lane, T. E., Pierce, J. R., and Pandis, S. N.: Rethinking organic aerosols: Semivolatile emissions and photochemical aging, Science, 315, 1259–1262, 2007.
Schauer, J. J., Rogge, W. F., Hildemann, L., M., Mazurek, M. A., Cass, G. R., and Simoneit, B. R. T.: Source apportionment of airborne particulate matter using organic compounds as tracers, Atmos. Environ., 30, 3837–3855, 1996.
Subramanian, R., Donahue, N. M., Bernardo-Bricker, A., Rogge, W. F., and Robinson, A. L.: Contribution of motor vehicle emissions to organic carbon and fine particle mass in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: Effects of varying source profiles and seasonal trends in ambient marker concentrations, Atmos. Environ., 40, 8002–8019, 2006.
Sun, C., Lee, B. P., Huang, D., Jie Li, Y., Schurman, M. I., Louie, P. K. K., Luk, C., and Chan, C. K.: Continuous measurements at the urban roadside in an Asian megacity by Aerosol Chemical Speciation Monitor (ACSM): particulate matter characteristics during fall and winter seasons in Hong Kong, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 1713–1728, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-16-1713-2016, 2016.
Thornhill, D. A., Williams, A. E., Onasch, T. B., Wood, E., Herndon, S. C., Kolb, C. E., Knighton, W. B., Zavala, M., Molina, L. T., and Marr, L. C.: Application of positive matrix factorization to on-road measurements for source apportionment of diesel- and gasoline-powered vehicle emissions in Mexico City, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 3629–3644, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-10-3629-2010, 2010.
Transport Department: The Annual Traffic Census 2017, The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Hong Kong, 2018.
Wang, X. L., Ho, K. F., Chow, J. C., Kohl, S. D., Chan, C. S., Cui, L., Lee, S. C. F., Chen, L. W. A., Ho, S. S. H., Cheng, Y., and Watson, J. G.: Hong Kong vehicle emission changes from 2003 to 2015 in the Shing Mun Tunnel, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 52, 1085–1098, 2018.
Wang, Q. Q., He, X., Huang, X. H. H., Griffith, S. M., Feng, Y. M., Zhang, T., Zhang, Q. Y., Wu, D., and Yu, J. Z.: Impact of secondary organic aerosol tracers on tracer-based source apportionment of organic carbon and PM2.5: A case study in the Pearl River Delta, China, ACS Earth Space Chem., 1, 562–571, 2017.
Weitkamp, E. A., Lambe, A. T., Donahue, N. M., and Robinson, A. L.: Laboratory measurements of the heterogeneous oxidation of condensed-phase organic molecular makers for motor vehicle exhaust, Environ. Sci. Technol., 42, 7950–7956, 2008.
Wong, Y. K., Huang, X. H. H., Cheng, Y. Y., Louie, P. K. K., Yu, A. L. C., Tang, A. W. Y., Chan, D. H. L., and Yu, J. Z.: Estimating contributions of vehicular emissions to PM2.5 in a roadside environment: A multiple approach study, Sci. Total Environ., 672, 776–788, 2019.
Wu, C. and Yu, J. Z.: Evaluation of linear regression techniques for atmospheric applications: the importance of appropriate weighting, Atmos. Meas. Tech., 11, 1233–1250, https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-11-1233-2018, 2018.
Yao, D. W., Lyu, X. P., Murray, F., Morawska, L., Yu, W., Wang, J. Y., and Guo, H.: Continuous effectiveness of replacing catalytic converters on liquefied petroleum gas-fueled vehicles in Hong Kong, Sci. Total Environ., 648, 830–838, 2019.
Yu, J. Z. and Zhang, T.: Chemical speciation of PM2.5 filter samples – January 1 through December 31, 2017, Final report submitted to the Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department, The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (Ref. 16-02709), Hong Kong, 2018.
Yu, J. Z., Huang, X. H. H., Griffith, S. M., Yuan, Z. B., and Ng, W. M.: Integrated assessment on roadside air quality, Final report submitted to the Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department, The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (Ref. 12-00255), Hong Kong, 2016.
Zheng, M., Hagler, G. S. W., Ke, L., Bergin, M. H., Wang, F., Louie, P. K. K., Salmon, L., Sin, D. W. M., Yu, J. Z., and Schauer, J. J.: Composition and sources of carbonaceous aerosols at three contrasting sites in Hong Kong, J. Geophys. Res., 111, D20313, https://doi.org/10.1029/2006JD007074, 2006.