Technical note: Bimodality in mesospheric OH rotational population distributions and implications for temperature measurements
- Center for Geospace Studies, SRI International, Menlo Park, California, USA
Correspondence: Konstantinos S. Kalogerakis (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Emissions from the OH Meinel bands are routinely used to determine rotational temperatures that are considered proxies for the kinetic temperature near the mesopause region. Previous observations determined OH rotational temperatures that show a dependence on the vibrational level, with the temperature rising overall as the OH vibrational quantum number v increases. The source of this trend is not well understood and has generally been attributed to deviations from thermodynamic equilibrium. This technical note demonstrates that the existence of bimodal OH rotational population distributions is an inherent feature of rotational relaxation in gases and can provide an explanation for the previously reported temperature trend. The use of only a few lines from rotational transitions involving low rotational quantum numbers to determine rotational temperatures does not account for the bimodality of the OH rotational population distributions and leads to systematic errors overestimating the OH rotational temperature. This note presents selected examples, discusses the relevant implications, and considers strategies that could lead to more reliable OH rotational temperature determination.
The hydroxyl radical is an important species in the middle atmosphere of the Earth. At altitudes of around 87 km, the exothermic reaction of ozone with atomic hydrogen produces rotationally and vibrationally excited hydroxyl, OH(v), in vibrational levels v=5–9 (Adler-Golden, 1997; Khomich et al., 2008; von Savigny, 2017; and references therein). The radiative decay of OH(v) in the visible and infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, known as the OH Meinel band emission, is a prominent feature in night sky spectra. The OH Meinel band emission has been used to monitor atmospheric density changes, temperature fluctuations, and species concentrations for several decades (Meriwether, 1989; Sivjee, 1992; Khomich et al., 2008; Grygalashvyly, 2015).
Collisional relaxation of OH(v) by other atmospheric species plays an important role in determining the observed internal quantum-state distribution. As a result, collisional energy transfer between OH(v) and the major components of the atmosphere at this altitude region, O2 and N2, have been studied for many years. Nevertheless, several gaps persist in our knowledge of these processes. Especially for oxygen atoms, which form a significant component of the atmosphere at the high-altitude part of the OH(v) layer, studies of collisional energy transfer have been relatively limited. Notable recent developments from laboratory studies include the demonstration that the deactivation of OH(v=9) by O atoms is characterized by a total loss rate coefficient that is significantly larger than that by O2 and N2, and the most efficient relaxation pathway involves multi-quantum vibrational-to-electronic energy transfer (Kalogerakis et al., 2011, 2016).
The question of whether the OH rotational temperature determined by observations is equivalent to the local kinetic temperature is of fundamental significance and has been debated since the discovery of the Meinel band emission in the 1950s (Kalogerakis et al., 2018, and references therein). Simultaneous observations of mesospheric OH(v) emissions from several vibrational levels by Cosby and Slanger (2007) and Noll et al. (2015, 2016) using sky spectra from astronomical telescopes reported rotational temperatures that exhibit a clear vibrational level dependence; the rotational temperature increases by approximately 15 K as the OH vibrational quantum number increases from v=2 to v=8. Both groups also determined that the rotational temperature of OH(v=8) was significantly higher than that for OH(v=9). Figure 1 summarizes the results on OH rotational temperatures reported by Cosby and Slanger (2007), Oliva et al. (2015), and Noll et al. (2016). Despite some variation, possibly due to the different location, time, and instrument for these measurements, these data sets show a similar trend for the vibrational level dependence of the OH rotational temperatures. Additional details and the Oliva et al. (2015) data set can be found in the original publications as well as in Kalogerakis (2017).
In this technical note, we first briefly consider the available knowledge from fundamental theoretical and experimental studies of rotational energy transfer. These studies unambiguously demonstrate that bimodal rotational population distributions are an inherent feature of the rotational relaxation process in gases. Signatures of bimodal behavior have been observed in the laboratory as well as in the upper atmosphere. We then show that neglecting to account for this bimodality in the mesospheric OH rotational population distributions leads to large systematic errors in the determined rotational temperatures. These findings provide an explanation for the aforementioned dependence of the OH rotational temperatures on the vibrational level determined in previous studies. Finally, this note briefly discusses the implications for mesospheric temperature measurements and strategies for mitigation of systematic errors.
Before considering results from atmospheric observations, it is highly informative to review selected information from theoretical studies on the mechanism of rotational relaxation as well as relevant laboratory results.
In their seminal experiments on rotational energy transfer investigated with the technique of “arrested relaxation” using infrared chemiluminescence, John C. Polanyi and coworkers (Charters and Polanyi, 1962; Anlauf et al., 1967; Polanyi and Woodall, 1972) investigated how the initial highly rotationally excited nonthermal population distribution of hydrogen chloride from the H+Cl2 reaction attained thermal equilibrium in collisions with the bath gas. A general observation in these studies was that rotational energy transfer was less efficient as the rotational excitation increased or, in other words, as the energy spacing between rotational levels became larger. A key finding by Polanyi and coworkers was that rotational-to-translational (R–T) energy transfer of an initial rotationally excited population distribution peaking at high rotational quantum number J does not exhibit a transient peak at intermediate J values. Instead, a bimodal distribution is generated with a peak at high J, reflecting the nascent excited rotational population distribution, as well as a new secondary peak at low J, corresponding to the thermal distribution of the bath gas. As the rotational relaxation process progresses, the amplitude of the excited nonthermal population distribution decreases while that of the thermalized distribution increases accordingly. Polanyi and Woodall (1972) developed a theoretical model for R–T energy transfer that quantitatively accounted for their experimental observations. According to this model, the transition probability for rotational energy transfer decreases exponentially with the energy gap between the two rotational states involved in the rotational energy exchange. Figure 2 demonstrates the bimodal pattern observed when an initial rotational population distribution that is a delta function relaxes according to the model of Polanyi and Woodall (1972). Exponential-gap models have been extensively used in studies of rotational energy transfer for decades (Koszykowski et al., 1985; Lucht et al., 1986; Dodd et al., 1994; Holtzclaw et al., 1997; Beaud et al. 1998; Fei et al., 1998; Kliner and Farrow, 1999; Hickson et al., 2002; Knopp et al., 2003; Funke et al., 2012; Noll et al., 2018).
Regarding rotational relaxation involving the hydroxyl radical, Kliner and Farrow (1999) performed relevant laser-based experiments studying energy transfer in OH(v=0) excited to rotational levels N=1–12 near room temperature. In those studies, pulsed photolysis of H2O2 at 266 nm created a rotationally excited population distribution, whose temporal evolution was probed using laser-induced fluorescence (LIF). Kliner and Farrow (1999) were able to determine that rotational relaxation by O2 and N2 is more efficient for lower rotational levels than for higher ones. They also found that an exponential gap model similar to that of Polanyi and Woodall (1972) reproduced their laboratory measurements remarkably well. Figure 3 presents the results of Kliner and Farrow (1999) for rotationally excited OH(v=0, N=1–12) colliding with N2 bath gas. The figure also shows Boltzmann fits to the data of Kliner and Farrow (1999) using a fitting function described by two Boltzmann distributions, at low and high temperatures. The initially excited and the final thermalized distributions were fit to a single-temperature, indicated in Fig. 3. For the other measurements, we constrained the two determined temperatures as fixed values and varied the partitioning of the two rotational level populations at the two characteristic temperatures so as to reflect the changes in the degree of thermal equilibration. As Fig. 3 shows, this experimental system is well described by a low temperature value near room temperature and a high temperature value (293±4 and 1567±38 K, based on our fits) reflecting the nascent rotational distribution of OH(v=0) following photodissociation of H2O2. Gericke et al. (1986) performed a relevant laboratory study investigating the dynamics of H2O2 photodissociation at 266 nm and found that the nascent OH(v=0) product rotational state distribution was characterized by a temperature of 1530±150 K, in excellent agreement with the results of the fits shown in Fig. 3. We find similar agreement with the measurements of Kliner and Farrow (1999) for collider gases O2 and Ar. In summary, the results of Kliner and Farrow (1999) provide further validation for the exponential-gap rotational relaxation model of Polanyi and Woodall (1972) as well as a clear laboratory demonstration of bimodality in the OH product state distributions following rotational relaxation.
Atmospheric observations have revealed that the rotational population distributions of mesospheric OH display a bimodal character. Early observations provided the first indications for emission from lines associated with high rotational excitation in selected vibrational levels (Pendleton Jr. et al., 1989, 1993; Perminov and Semenov, 1992; Dodd et al., 1993; Perminov et al., 2007; and references therein). Recent simultaneous observations of multiple OH vibrational levels using high-resolution spectrographs from astronomical telescopes by Cosby and Slanger (2007) and Oliva et al. (2015) represent the most comprehensive demonstrations of bimodal behavior in OH(v) rotational population distributions to date. Bimodal behavior is evident for all observed vibrational levels OH(v=2–9), but this effect may appear at first less pronounced for the highest vibrational levels. In fact, the opposite is true because the higher the OH vibrational level is, the larger the fraction of the rotational level population that deviates from thermodynamic equilibrium. This behavior results from the fact that the OH(v) radiative lifetime decreases as the vibrational level increases (Brooke et al., 2016) and, consequently, the higher OH vibrational levels experience fewer collisions with the ambient atmosphere. In principle, more complex behavior than bimodal might be possible because of the large number of production and removal pathways for mesospheric OH(v). Hints of additional features may be discerned for v=3–5 in the data of Oliva et al. (2015), but these are at best tentative given the signal-to-noise ratio. Additional measurements at high resolution and sensitivity combined with careful corrections for any absorption and spectral interferences will be required to settle this question. Based on the available information to date, it appears that to a first approximation the simplest adequate description of the mesospheric OH(v) rotational population distributions is that of bimodal Boltzmann distributions.
We now consider the effect of bimodal OH rotational population distributions on the determination of OH rotational temperatures by considering an example for OH(v=9). This is the highest populated vibrational level and most probable product of the H+O3 reaction. Collisional cascade from higher vibrational levels can be assumed to be a limited, and most likely negligible, source. Therefore, more than any other OH vibrational level, rotational relaxation of v=9 is expected to follow the exponential-gap model of Polanyi and Woodall (1972). Figure 4 presents the observed rotational population distribution reported by Noll et al. (2018) for v=9 together with fits we performed using one simple and one bimodal Boltzmann distribution function. In the former case, only rotational lines with energy less than 250 cm−1 are considered. From Fig. 4, we conclude that neglecting the bimodal behavior of the rotational population distributions and considering only a few rotational lines involving the lowest quantum numbers leads to unacceptably large systematic errors in the extracted OH rotational temperatures. The lower temperature value for the bulk of the population obtained from the fit using a two-temperature bimodal Boltzmann distribution is 20 K lower than the temperature obtained using a single Boltzmann function and only a few low-level rotational transitions.
We recently considered two-temperature fits for selected OH vibrational bands from the Oliva et al. (2015) data set (Kalogerakis et al., 2018). The OH(v) rotational temperatures inferred from single and two-temperature Boltzmann distribution functions are generally different. Based on the information above, it becomes clear the observed trend for single-temperature fits does not reflect real temperature changes; it is an artifact that arises from neglecting the bimodal character of the OH rotational population distribution. Although this effect is most pronounced for the largest OH(v) levels, e.g., v=8, 9, differences for the lowest observed vibrational levels, v=2, 3, appear to be comparable to the estimated uncertainties. The majority of the OH(v) product from the H+O3 reaction is generated in the highly vibrationally excited levels v=7–9, while collisional or radiative relaxation is needed to generate the lowest vibrational levels. Thus, it is reasonable to expect that the lower vibrational levels have undergone more extensive thermalization. At the same time, however, we do not fully understand all the relevant collisional relaxation processes and the variability of the bimodal character in the OH rotational population distributions. Thus, although we could state with confidence that not accounting for the bimodality in the rotational population distributions introduces large systematic errors for the highest OH vibrational levels, it is presently difficult to assess the extent to which changes in the rotational temperatures for OH(low-v) are influenced by variations in the fraction of the rotational population distribution that is not in thermal equilibrium.
The most important finding of this technical note is the demonstration that the traditional approach in aeronomy to determine OH rotational temperatures using only a pair or a few rotational lines involving the lowest rotational quantum levels does not account for the bimodality of the observed mesospheric OH rotational population distributions and can lead to unacceptably large systematic errors in the OH rotational temperature determination, especially for OH(high v). To mitigate this problem, the recommended approach would be to concurrently obtain information on the non-equilibrated, high-rotational-level tail of the OH(v) rotational population distribution. The adequate resolution and sensitivity to record the full rotational population distribution may not always be available, but even establishing a lower limit for the ratio of the high-rotational-level population versus the low-rotational-level population would be helpful in assessing potential systematic errors. Without this type of information, it is not clear what portion of the observed variability in the OH rotational temperature of any specific vibrational level could be attributed to changes in the non-thermalized rotational population.
Evidence from theoretical calculations and laboratory experiments demonstrates that rotational energy transfer between a Boltzmann distribution of rotationally excited molecules and a thermal bath leads to bimodal distributions. Such behavior has indeed been reported in atmospheric observations of mesospheric OH. The common approach in aeronomy of considering only a few OH rotational lines with the lowest rotational excitation to determine the rotational temperature does not account for the bimodality of the OH(v) rotational population distributions and can lead to large systematic errors overestimating the rotational temperature. These errors are largest for the highest OH(v) vibrational levels and their magnitude can reach several degrees Kelvin. This effect provides an explanation for the apparent vibrational-level dependence of OH rotational temperatures reported from previous atmospheric observations. Careful consideration of the highly rotationally excited portion of the rotational population distributions under study is required for a reliable determination of rotational temperatures from mesospheric OH(v) Meinel band observations.
The data set from Oliva et al. (2015) presented here and information relevant to the analysis are available on the Open Science Framework website https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/NKWPJ (Kalogerakis, 2017).
The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
This article is part of the special issue “Layered phenomena in the mesopause region (ACP/AMT inter-journal SI)”. It is a result of the LPMR workshop 2017 (LPMR-2017), Kühlungsborn, Germany, 18–22 September 2017.
The material presented here is based in part on work supported by the US
National Science Foundation (NSF) grant AGS-1441896, NASA grant
80NSSC17K0638, and SRI International research and development funds. The author thanks Philip C. Cosby,
Tom G. Slanger, and Stefan Noll for helpful discussions.
Edited by: Franz-Josef Lübken
Reviewed by: two anonymous referees
Adler-Golden, S.: Kinetic parameters for OH nightglow modeling consistent with recent laboratory measurements, J. Geophys. Res., 102, 19969–19976, 1997.
Anlauf, K. G., Kuntz, P. J., Maylotte, D. H., Pacey, P. D., and Polanyi, J. C.: Energy distribution among reaction products. Part 2. – H+X2 and X+HY, Discuss. Faraday Soc. 44, 183–193, https://doi.org/10.1039/DF9674400183, 1967.
Beaud, P., Radi, P. P., Franzke, D., Frey, H.-M., Mischler, B., Tzannis, A. P., and Gerber, T.: Picosecond investigation of the collisional deactivation of OH A2Σ+(v, N, 12) in an atmospheric-pressure flame, Appl. Opt., 37, 3354–3367, 1998.
Brooke, J. S. A., Bernath, P. F., Western, C. M., Sneden, C., Afşar, M., Li, G., and Gordon, I. E.: Line strengths of rovibrational and rotational transitions in the X2Π ground state of OH, J. Quant. Spectrosc. Ra., 168, 142–157, 2016.
Charters, P. E. and Polanyi, J. C.: Energy distribution among reaction products. Part 1 – The reaction atomic hydrogen plus molecular chlorine, Faraday Soc. Discuss., 33, 107–117, 1962.
Cosby, P. C. and Slanger, T. G.: OH spectroscopy and chemistry investigated with astronomical sky spectra, Can. J. Phys., 85, 77–99, 2007.
Dodd, J. A., Blumberg, W. A. M., Lipson, S. J., Lowell, J. R., Armstrong, P. S., Smith, D. R., and Huppi, E. R.: OH(v, N) column densities from high-resolution Earth-limb spectra, Geophys. Res. Lett., 20, 305–308, 1993.
Dodd, J. A., Lipson, S. J., Lowell, J. R., Armstrong, P. S., Blumberg, W. A. M., Nadile, R. M., and Green, B. D.: Analysis of hydroxyl Earthlimb airglow emissions: Kinetic model for state-to-state dynamics of OH (v, N), J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 99, 3559–3585, 1994.
Fei, R., Lambert, H. M., Carrington, T., Filseth, S. V., Sadowski, C. M., and Dugan, C. H.: Direct measurement of thermal rate constants for state-to-state rotational energy transfer in collisions of CN(XΣ2Σ+, v =2, N) with He, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 1190–1201, 1998.
Funke, B., López-Puertas, M., García-Comas, M., Kaufmann, M., Höpfner, M., and Stiller, G. P.: GRANADA: a Generic RAdiative traNsfer AnD non-LTE population algorithm, J. Quant. Spectrosc. Ra., 113, 1771–1817, 2012.
Gericke, K.-H., Klee, S., Comes, F. J., and Dixon, R. N.: Dynamics of H2O2 photodissociation: OH product state and momentum distribution characterized by sub-Doppler and polarization spectroscopy, J. Chem. Phys., 85, 4463–4479, 1986.
Grygalashvyly, M.: Several notes on the OH* layer, Ann. Geophys., 33, 923–930, https://doi.org/10.5194/angeo-33-923-2015, 2015.
Hickson, K. M., Sadowski, C. M., and Smith, I. W. M.: Rate coefficients for rotational energy transfer from the levels OH(X2Π3∕2, v =1, j = 3.5–8.5) in collisions with He, Ar, N2 and HNO3, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 4, 5613–5621, 2002.
Holtzclaw, K. W., Upschulte, B. L., Caledonia, G. E., Cronin, J. F., Green, B. D., Lipson, S. J., Blumberg, W. A. M., and Dodd, J. A.: Rotational relaxation of high-N states of OH (X2Π, v =1–3) by O2, J. Geophys. Res., 102, 4521–4528, 1997.
Kalogerakis, K. S.: Data set from Oliva et al. (2015), https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/NKWPJ, 2017.
Kalogerakis, K. S., Smith, G. P., and Copeland, R. A.: Collisional removal of OH(X2Π, v = 9) by O, O2, O3, N2, and CO2, J. Geophys. Res., 116, D20307, https://doi.org/10.1029/2011JD015734, 2011.
Kalogerakis, K. S., Matsiev, D., Sharma, R., and Wintersteiner, P. W.: Resolving the mesospheric nighttime 4.3 µm emission puzzle: Laboratory demonstration of new mechanism for OH(v) relaxation, Geophys. Res. Lett., 43, 8835–8843, https://doi.org/10.1002/2016GL069645, 2016.
Kalogerakis, K. S., Matsiev, D., Cosby, P. C., Dodd, J. A., Falcinelli, S., Hedin, J., Kutepov, A. A., Noll, S., Panka, P. A., Romanescu, C., and Thiebaud, J. E.: New insights for mesospheric OH: multi-quantum vibrational relaxation as a driver for non-local thermodynamic equilibrium, Ann. Geophys., 36, 13–24, https://doi.org/10.5194/angeo-36-13-2018, 2018.
Khomich, V. Y., Semenov, A. I., and Shefov, N. N.: Airglow as an Indicator of Upper Atmospheric Structure and Dynamics, Springer, Germany, 415–449, 2008.
Kliner, D. A. and Farrow, R. L.: Measurements of ground-state OH rotational energy-transfer rates, J. Chem. Phys., 110, 412–422, 1999.
Knopp, G., Radi, P., Tulej, M., Gerber, T., and Beaud, P.: Collision induced rotational energy transfer probed by time-resolved coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering, J. Chem. Phys. 118, 8223–8233, https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1566437, 2003.
Koszykowski, M. L., Farrow, R. L., and Palmer, R. E.: Calculation of collisionally narrowed coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectroscopy spectra, Opt. Lett., 10, 478–480, 1985.
Lucht, R. P., Sweeney, D. W., and Laurendeau, N. M.: Time-resolved fluorescence investigation of rotational transfer in A2Σ+ (v =0) OH, Appl. Opt., 25, 4086–4095, 1986.
Meriwether, J. W.: A review of the photochemistry of selected nightglow emissions from the mesopause, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 94, 14629–14646, 1989.
Noll, S., Kausch, W., Kimeswenger, S., Unterguggenberger, S., and Jones, A. M.: OH populations and temperatures from simultaneous spectroscopic observations of 25 bands, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 3647–3669, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-3647-2015, 2015.
Noll, S., Kausch, W., Kimeswenger, S., Unterguggenberger, S., and Jones, A. M.: Comparison of VLT/X-shooter OH and O2 rotational temperatures with consideration of TIMED/SABER emission and temperature profiles, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 5021–5042, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-16-5021-2016, 2016.
Noll, S., Proxauf, B., Kausch, W., and Kimeswenger, S.: Mechanisms for varying non-LTE contributions to OH rotational temperatures from measurements and modelling. II. Kinetic model, J. Atmos. Sol.-Terr. Phy., 175, 100–119, 2018.
Oliva, E., Origlia, L., Scuderi, S., Benatti, S., Carleo, I., Lapenna, E., Mucciarelli, A., Baffa, C., Biliotti, V., Carbonaro, L., Falcini, G., Giani, E., Iuzzolino, M., Massi, F., Sanna, N., Sozzi, M., Tozzi, A., Ghedina, A., Ghinassi, F., Lodi, M., Harutyunyan, A., and Pedani, M.: Lines and continuum sky emission in the near infrared: observational constraints from deep high spectral resolution spectra with GIANO-TNG, Astron. Astrophys., 581, 1–6, https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201526291, 2015.
Pendleton Jr., W., Espy, P., Baker, D., Steed, A., Fetrow, M., and Henriksen, K.: Observation of OH Meinel (7, 4) P(N D 13) transitions in the night airglow, J. Geophys. Res., 94, 505–510, https://doi.org/10.1029/JA094iA01p00505, 1989.
Pendleton Jr., W. R., Espy, P. J., and Hammond, M. R.: Evidence for non-local-thermodynamic-equilibrium rotation in the OH nightglow, J. Geophys. Res.-Space, 98, 11567–11579, 1993.
Perminov, V. I. and Semenov, A. I.: The nonequilibrium of the rotational temperature of OH bands under high level rotational excitation, Geomagn. Aeronomy, 32, 306–308, 1992.
Perminov, V. I., Semenov, A. I., and Shefov, N. N.: On rotational temperature of the hydroxyl emission, Geomagn. Aeronomy, 47, 756–763, 2007.
Polanyi, J. C. and Woodall, K. B.: Mechanism of rotational relaxation, J. Chem. Phys., 56, 1563–1572, 1972.
Sivjee, G. G.: Airglow hydroxyl emissions, Planet. Space Sci., 40, 235–242, 1992.
von Savigny, C.: Airglow in the Earth atmosphere: basic characteristics and excitation mechanisms, ChemTexts, 3, 14, https://doi.org/10.1007/s40828-017-0051-y, 2017.