X-ray computed microtomography of sea ice – comment on "A review of air–ice chemical and physical interactions (AICI): liquids, quasi-liquids, and solids in snow" by Bartels-Rausch et al. (2014)

Obbard, R. W.

doi:10.5194/acp-15-8457-2015

Articles | Volume 15, issue 14

https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-8457-2015

© Author(s) 2015. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Special issue:

New perspectives on Air-Ice Chemical Interactions (AICI) (ACP/ESSD...

https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-8457-2015

© Author(s) 2015. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Articles | Volume 15, issue 14

Peer-reviewed comment

|

29 Jul 2015

Peer-reviewed comment |

| 29 Jul 2015

X-ray computed microtomography of sea ice – comment on "A review of air–ice chemical and physical interactions (AICI): liquids, quasi-liquids, and solids in snow" by Bartels-Rausch et al. (2014)

R. W. Obbard

Viewed

Total article views: 3,337 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	BibTeX	EndNote
2,089	1,113	135	3,337	185	255

HTML: 2,089
PDF: 1,113
XML: 135
Total: 3,337
BibTeX: 185
EndNote: 255

Views and downloads (calculated since 05 May 2015)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
May 2015	41	57	5	103
Jun 2015	12	11	2	25
Jul 2015	68	46	4	118
Aug 2015	40	30	4	74
Sep 2015	16	23	1	40
Oct 2015	30	8	1	39
Nov 2015	45	27	4	76
Dec 2015	17	17	3	37
Jan 2016	32	14	4	50
Feb 2016	27	10	0	37
Mar 2016	24	7	0	31
Apr 2016	10	5	0	15
May 2016	10	4	1	15
Jun 2016	11	5	2	18
Jul 2016	10	14	3	27
Aug 2016	11	2	0	13
Sep 2016	12	4	0	16
Oct 2016	13	3	0	16
Nov 2016	9	1	0	10
Dec 2016	7	3	0	10
Jan 2017	20	4	0	24
Feb 2017	14	2	1	17
Mar 2017	19	4	1	24
Apr 2017	26	10	1	37
May 2017	23	9	1	33
Jun 2017	27	5	1	33
Jul 2017	22	2	0	24
Aug 2017	13	9	1	23
Sep 2017	8	9	1	18
Oct 2017	12	7	0	19
Nov 2017	15	7	0	22
Dec 2017	8	6	0	14
Jan 2018	7	4	0	11
Feb 2018	3	6	0	9
Mar 2018	14	10	1	25
Apr 2018	10	11	2	23
May 2018	10	8	0	18
Jun 2018	11	8	0	19
Jul 2018	7	4	0	11
Aug 2018	10	8	0	18
Sep 2018	7	11	0	18
Oct 2018	15	5	1	21
Nov 2018	9	4	0	13
Dec 2018	11	5	1	17
Jan 2019	4	5	0	9
Feb 2019	4	2	0	6
Mar 2019	6	5	0	11
Apr 2019	7	5	0	12
May 2019	7	3	0	10
Jun 2019	5	1	0	6
Jul 2019	10	7	1	18
Aug 2019	5	5	0	10
Sep 2019	1	3	0	4
Oct 2019	6	3	0	9
Nov 2019	7	2	1	10
Dec 2019	7	5	0	12
Jan 2020	6	2	0	8
Feb 2020	8	5	1	14
Mar 2020	2	3	0	5
Apr 2020	3	3	0	6
May 2020	8	4	0	12
Jun 2020	18	3	0	21
Jul 2020	19	11	5	35
Aug 2020	8	4	4	16
Sep 2020	10	5	0	15
Oct 2020	7	2	1	10
Nov 2020	8	2	1	11
Dec 2020	12	7	0	19
Jan 2021	18	10	0	28
Feb 2021	12	2	0	14
Mar 2021	6	2	0	8
Apr 2021	9	4	0	13
May 2021	7	5	1	13
Jun 2021	8	6	0	14
Jul 2021	7	2	0	9
Aug 2021	5	11	0	16
Sep 2021	9	9	0	18
Oct 2021	5	32	0	37
Nov 2021	13	25	0	38
Dec 2021	10	8	0	18
Jan 2022	11	8	0	19
Feb 2022	8	5	0	13
Mar 2022	4	3	0	7
Apr 2022	5	4	1	10
May 2022	3	3	0	6
Jun 2022	3	1	0	4
Jul 2022	2	5	0	7
Aug 2022	7	2	0	9
Sep 2022	6	2	0	8
Oct 2022	7	2	0	9
Nov 2022	6	2	0	8
Dec 2022	14	2	0	16
Jan 2023	5	8	0	13
Feb 2023	8	5	0	13
Mar 2023	9	2	0	11
Apr 2023	6	3	0	9
May 2023	35	6	0	41
Jun 2023	42	5	1	48
Jul 2023	35	3	0	38
Aug 2023	33	6	2	41
Sep 2023	37	3	1	41
Oct 2023	39	10	2	51
Nov 2023	29	3	0	32
Dec 2023	39	5	3	47
Jan 2024	36	6	0	42
Feb 2024	34	7	0	41
Mar 2024	40	10	2	52
Apr 2024	41	10	6	57
May 2024	9	8	1	18
Jun 2024	16	7	2	25
Jul 2024	13	10	2	25
Aug 2024	22	4	0	26
Sep 2024	10	5	0	15
Oct 2024	15	9	0	24
Nov 2024	4	1	3	8
Dec 2024	3	5	0	8
Jan 2025	16	8	3	27
Feb 2025	20	5	5	30
Mar 2025	19	8	0	27
Apr 2025	5	9	5	19
May 2025	14	4	0	18
Jun 2025	37	8	1	46
Jul 2025	16	17	2	35
Aug 2025	19	20	0	39
Sep 2025	34	17	1	52
Oct 2025	24	24	0	48
Nov 2025	28	21	6	55
Dec 2025	28	30	1	59
Jan 2026	29	11	6	46
Feb 2026	28	20	2	50
Mar 2026	21	29	6	56
Apr 2026	31	29	4	64
May 2026	19	9	4	32
Jun 2026	12	2	2	16

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 05 May 2015)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
May 2015	41	57	5	103
Jun 2015	12	11	2	25
Jul 2015	68	46	4	118
Aug 2015	40	30	4	74
Sep 2015	16	23	1	40
Oct 2015	30	8	1	39
Nov 2015	45	27	4	76
Dec 2015	17	17	3	37
Jan 2016	32	14	4	50
Feb 2016	27	10	0	37
Mar 2016	24	7	0	31
Apr 2016	10	5	0	15
May 2016	10	4	1	15
Jun 2016	11	5	2	18
Jul 2016	10	14	3	27
Aug 2016	11	2	0	13
Sep 2016	12	4	0	16
Oct 2016	13	3	0	16
Nov 2016	9	1	0	10
Dec 2016	7	3	0	10
Jan 2017	20	4	0	24
Feb 2017	14	2	1	17
Mar 2017	19	4	1	24
Apr 2017	26	10	1	37
May 2017	23	9	1	33
Jun 2017	27	5	1	33
Jul 2017	22	2	0	24
Aug 2017	13	9	1	23
Sep 2017	8	9	1	18
Oct 2017	12	7	0	19
Nov 2017	15	7	0	22
Dec 2017	8	6	0	14
Jan 2018	7	4	0	11
Feb 2018	3	6	0	9
Mar 2018	14	10	1	25
Apr 2018	10	11	2	23
May 2018	10	8	0	18
Jun 2018	11	8	0	19
Jul 2018	7	4	0	11
Aug 2018	10	8	0	18
Sep 2018	7	11	0	18
Oct 2018	15	5	1	21
Nov 2018	9	4	0	13
Dec 2018	11	5	1	17
Jan 2019	4	5	0	9
Feb 2019	4	2	0	6
Mar 2019	6	5	0	11
Apr 2019	7	5	0	12
May 2019	7	3	0	10
Jun 2019	5	1	0	6
Jul 2019	10	7	1	18
Aug 2019	5	5	0	10
Sep 2019	1	3	0	4
Oct 2019	6	3	0	9
Nov 2019	7	2	1	10
Dec 2019	7	5	0	12
Jan 2020	6	2	0	8
Feb 2020	8	5	1	14
Mar 2020	2	3	0	5
Apr 2020	3	3	0	6
May 2020	8	4	0	12
Jun 2020	18	3	0	21
Jul 2020	19	11	5	35
Aug 2020	8	4	4	16
Sep 2020	10	5	0	15
Oct 2020	7	2	1	10
Nov 2020	8	2	1	11
Dec 2020	12	7	0	19
Jan 2021	18	10	0	28
Feb 2021	12	2	0	14
Mar 2021	6	2	0	8
Apr 2021	9	4	0	13
May 2021	7	5	1	13
Jun 2021	8	6	0	14
Jul 2021	7	2	0	9
Aug 2021	5	11	0	16
Sep 2021	9	9	0	18
Oct 2021	5	32	0	37
Nov 2021	13	25	0	38
Dec 2021	10	8	0	18
Jan 2022	11	8	0	19
Feb 2022	8	5	0	13
Mar 2022	4	3	0	7
Apr 2022	5	4	1	10
May 2022	3	3	0	6
Jun 2022	3	1	0	4
Jul 2022	2	5	0	7
Aug 2022	7	2	0	9
Sep 2022	6	2	0	8
Oct 2022	7	2	0	9
Nov 2022	6	2	0	8
Dec 2022	14	2	0	16
Jan 2023	5	8	0	13
Feb 2023	8	5	0	13
Mar 2023	9	2	0	11
Apr 2023	6	3	0	9
May 2023	35	6	0	41
Jun 2023	42	5	1	48
Jul 2023	35	3	0	38
Aug 2023	33	6	2	41
Sep 2023	37	3	1	41
Oct 2023	39	10	2	51
Nov 2023	29	3	0	32
Dec 2023	39	5	3	47
Jan 2024	36	6	0	42
Feb 2024	34	7	0	41
Mar 2024	40	10	2	52
Apr 2024	41	10	6	57
May 2024	9	8	1	18
Jun 2024	16	7	2	25
Jul 2024	13	10	2	25
Aug 2024	22	4	0	26
Sep 2024	10	5	0	15
Oct 2024	15	9	0	24
Nov 2024	4	1	3	8
Dec 2024	3	5	0	8
Jan 2025	16	8	3	27
Feb 2025	20	5	5	30
Mar 2025	19	8	0	27
Apr 2025	5	9	5	19
May 2025	14	4	0	18
Jun 2025	37	8	1	46
Jul 2025	16	17	2	35
Aug 2025	19	20	0	39
Sep 2025	34	17	1	52
Oct 2025	24	24	0	48
Nov 2025	28	21	6	55
Dec 2025	28	30	1	59
Jan 2026	29	11	6	46
Feb 2026	28	20	2	50
Mar 2026	21	29	6	56
Apr 2026	31	29	4	64
May 2026	19	9	4	32
Jun 2026	12	2	2	16

Cited

Saved (final revised paper)

Latest update: 12 Jun 2026

Short summary

This paper, "X-ray computed microtomography of sea ice" is a comment on a recent paper, "A review of air–ice chemical and physical interactions (AICI): liquids, quasi-liquids, and solids in snow (Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 1587–1633, 2014)". Our paper corrects a part of the review paper, which was inaccurate regarding the capabilities of X-ray computed microtomography to reveal liquid brine inclusions in sea ice.

X-ray computed microtomography of sea ice – comment on "A review of air–ice chemical and physical interactions (AICI): liquids, quasi-liquids, and solids in snow" by Bartels-Rausch et al. (2014)

Viewed

Cited

2 citations as recorded by crossref.

2 citations as recorded by crossref.

Saved (final revised paper)