Commentary on ''Measurements of ice supersaturations exceeding 100% at the cold tropical tropopause'' by E. Jensen et al.

Murphy, D. M.

doi:https://doi.org/10.5194/acpd-5-2463-2005

Preprints

https://doi.org/10.5194/acpd-5-2463-2005

Preprints

22 Apr 2005

| 22 Apr 2005

Status: this preprint was under review for the journal ACP. A revision for further review has not been submitted.

Commentary on ''Measurements of ice supersaturations exceeding 100% at the cold tropical tropopause'' by E. Jensen et al.

D. M. Murphy

Abstract. The paper by Jensen et al. (2005) provides an excellent use of a microphysical model to examine the logical consequences of high saturation ratios indicated by measurements during a high altitude flight of the NASA WB-57F. I would like to comment on a turn made by the aircraft that makes this particular event harder to interpret.

Received: 15 Mar 2005 – Discussion started: 22 Apr 2005

Download & links

D. M. Murphy

Status: closed (peer review stopped)

AC: Author comment | RC: Referee comment | SC: Short comment | EC: Editor comment

- Printer-friendly version

- Supplement

RC S702: 'Review of commentary by Murphy', Anonymous Referee #2, 06 May 2005
- AC S1228: 'Author reply', Daniel Murphy, 16 Jun 2005
RC S797: 'Referee comment', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 May 2005
- AC S1225: 'Author reply', Daniel Murphy, 16 Jun 2005
AC S891: 'Correction to Figure 2', Daniel Murphy, 24 May 2005
SC S1285: 'Comment', Eric Jensen, 20 Jun 2005

Status: closed (peer review stopped)

AC: Author comment | RC: Referee comment | SC: Short comment | EC: Editor comment

- Printer-friendly version

- Supplement

RC S702: 'Review of commentary by Murphy', Anonymous Referee #2, 06 May 2005
- AC S1228: 'Author reply', Daniel Murphy, 16 Jun 2005
RC S797: 'Referee comment', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 May 2005
- AC S1225: 'Author reply', Daniel Murphy, 16 Jun 2005
AC S891: 'Correction to Figure 2', Daniel Murphy, 24 May 2005
SC S1285: 'Comment', Eric Jensen, 20 Jun 2005

D. M. Murphy

Viewed

Total article views: 1,032 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	BibTeX	EndNote
673	241	118	1,032	126	100

HTML: 673
PDF: 241
XML: 118
Total: 1,032
BibTeX: 126
EndNote: 100

Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	4	8	2	14
Mar 2013	5	0	5
Apr 2013	4	0	4
May 2013	7	0	7
Jun 2013	2	5	0	7
Jul 2013	4	0	4
Aug 2013	2	4	1	7
Sep 2013	2	5	0	7
Oct 2013	4	0	4
Nov 2013	5	0	5
Dec 2013	4	0	4
Jan 2014	8	0	8
Feb 2014	4	8	2	14
Mar 2014	4	6	0	10
Apr 2014	1	5	0	6
May 2014	6	0	6
Jun 2014	4	0	4
Jul 2014	1	7	0	8
Aug 2014	4	8	2	14
Sep 2014	3	7	2	12
Oct 2014	2	5	0	7
Nov 2014	2	9	0	11
Dec 2014	7	0	7
Jan 2015	1	3	0	4
Feb 2015	1	1	0	2
Mar 2015	8	2	1	11
Apr 2015	12	1	13
May 2015	5	2	3	10
Jun 2015	6	3	9
Jul 2015	9	1	1	11
Aug 2015	3	1	2	6
Sep 2015	1	20	21
Oct 2015	6	0	6
Nov 2015	10	3	5	18
Dec 2015	2	7	9
Jan 2016	10	3	2	15
Feb 2016	10	2	2	14
Mar 2016	7	3	0	10
Apr 2016	7	4	1	12
May 2016	7	1	0	8
Jun 2016	4	1	2	7
Jul 2016	6	1	1	8
Aug 2016	3	2	1	6
Sep 2016	3	0	3
Oct 2016	4	4	8
Nov 2016	5	6	11
Dec 2016	3	3	0	6
Jan 2017	5	2	7
Feb 2017	9	1	10
Mar 2017	25	5	30
Apr 2017	22	1	6	29
May 2017	35	1	3	39
Jun 2017	23	1	24
Jul 2017	6	0	6
Aug 2017	1	1	0	2
Sep 2017	6	0	6
Oct 2017	1	2	0	3
Nov 2017	3	0	3
Dec 2017	4	2	0	6
Jan 2018	2	1	0	3
Feb 2018	1	0	1
Mar 2018	6	1	0	7
Apr 2018	6	2	0	8
May 2018	5	2	0	7
Jun 2018	3	2	0	5
Jul 2018	2	1	0	3
Aug 2018	6	3	2	11
Sep 2018	2	1	0	3
Oct 2018	5	1	0	6
Nov 2018	3	1	0	4
Dec 2018	4	2	0	6
Jan 2019	1	1	0	2
Feb 2019	1	0	1
Mar 2019	4	1	0	5
Apr 2019	4	1	0	5
May 2019	11	1	0	12
Jun 2019	1	1	0	2
Jul 2019	1	0	1
Aug 2019	4	0	4
Sep 2019	3	0	3
Oct 2019	3	1	4
Nov 2019	4	1	1	6
Dec 2019	1	1	0	2
Jan 2020	5	0	5
Feb 2020	1	1	2
Mar 2020	1	1	2
Apr 2020	3	0	3
May 2020	3	1	4
Jun 2020	10	0	10
Jul 2020	8	3	2	13
Aug 2020	3	1	2	6
Sep 2020	3	2	0	5
Oct 2020	5	3	0	8
Nov 2020	6	5	1	12
Dec 2020	6	1	0	7
Jan 2021	8	1	0	9
Feb 2021	6	2	0	8
Mar 2021	3	0	3
Apr 2021	7	0	7
May 2021	7	2	0	9
Jun 2021	5	0	5
Jul 2021	6	0	6
Aug 2021	9	0	9
Sep 2021	12	0	12
Oct 2021	5	0	5
Nov 2021	10	6	0	16
Dec 2021	9	1	0	10
Jan 2022	9	0	9
Feb 2022	5	0	5
Mar 2022	6	2	8
Apr 2022	5	0	5
May 2022	3	1	4
Jun 2022	1	1	2
Jul 2022	0
Aug 2022	3	1	0	4
Sep 2022	3	0	3
Oct 2022	2	1	0	3
Nov 2022	4	1	0	5
Dec 2022	3	1	0	4
Jan 2023	5	0	5
Feb 2023	5	3	1	9
Mar 2023	11	0	11
Apr 2023	2	0	2
May 2023	4	1	5
Jun 2023	3	0	3
Jul 2023	5	1	6
Aug 2023	7	1	0	8
Sep 2023	9	1	2	12
Oct 2023	4	0	4
Nov 2023	3	1	3	7
Dec 2023	5	0	5
Jan 2024	6	0	6
Feb 2024	7	1	2	10
Mar 2024	18	1	2	21
Apr 2024	9	1	1	11

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	4	8	2	14
Mar 2013	5	0	5
Apr 2013	4	0	4
May 2013	7	0	7
Jun 2013	2	5	0	7
Jul 2013	4	0	4
Aug 2013	2	4	1	7
Sep 2013	2	5	0	7
Oct 2013	4	0	4
Nov 2013	5	0	5
Dec 2013	4	0	4
Jan 2014	8	0	8
Feb 2014	4	8	2	14
Mar 2014	4	6	0	10
Apr 2014	1	5	0	6
May 2014	6	0	6
Jun 2014	4	0	4
Jul 2014	1	7	0	8
Aug 2014	4	8	2	14
Sep 2014	3	7	2	12
Oct 2014	2	5	0	7
Nov 2014	2	9	0	11
Dec 2014	7	0	7
Jan 2015	1	3	0	4
Feb 2015	1	1	0	2
Mar 2015	8	2	1	11
Apr 2015	12	1	13
May 2015	5	2	3	10
Jun 2015	6	3	9
Jul 2015	9	1	1	11
Aug 2015	3	1	2	6
Sep 2015	1	20	21
Oct 2015	6	0	6
Nov 2015	10	3	5	18
Dec 2015	2	7	9
Jan 2016	10	3	2	15
Feb 2016	10	2	2	14
Mar 2016	7	3	0	10
Apr 2016	7	4	1	12
May 2016	7	1	0	8
Jun 2016	4	1	2	7
Jul 2016	6	1	1	8
Aug 2016	3	2	1	6
Sep 2016	3	0	3
Oct 2016	4	4	8
Nov 2016	5	6	11
Dec 2016	3	3	0	6
Jan 2017	5	2	7
Feb 2017	9	1	10
Mar 2017	25	5	30
Apr 2017	22	1	6	29
May 2017	35	1	3	39
Jun 2017	23	1	24
Jul 2017	6	0	6
Aug 2017	1	1	0	2
Sep 2017	6	0	6
Oct 2017	1	2	0	3
Nov 2017	3	0	3
Dec 2017	4	2	0	6
Jan 2018	2	1	0	3
Feb 2018	1	0	1
Mar 2018	6	1	0	7
Apr 2018	6	2	0	8
May 2018	5	2	0	7
Jun 2018	3	2	0	5
Jul 2018	2	1	0	3
Aug 2018	6	3	2	11
Sep 2018	2	1	0	3
Oct 2018	5	1	0	6
Nov 2018	3	1	0	4
Dec 2018	4	2	0	6
Jan 2019	1	1	0	2
Feb 2019	1	0	1
Mar 2019	4	1	0	5
Apr 2019	4	1	0	5
May 2019	11	1	0	12
Jun 2019	1	1	0	2
Jul 2019	1	0	1
Aug 2019	4	0	4
Sep 2019	3	0	3
Oct 2019	3	1	4
Nov 2019	4	1	1	6
Dec 2019	1	1	0	2
Jan 2020	5	0	5
Feb 2020	1	1	2
Mar 2020	1	1	2
Apr 2020	3	0	3
May 2020	3	1	4
Jun 2020	10	0	10
Jul 2020	8	3	2	13
Aug 2020	3	1	2	6
Sep 2020	3	2	0	5
Oct 2020	5	3	0	8
Nov 2020	6	5	1	12
Dec 2020	6	1	0	7
Jan 2021	8	1	0	9
Feb 2021	6	2	0	8
Mar 2021	3	0	3
Apr 2021	7	0	7
May 2021	7	2	0	9
Jun 2021	5	0	5
Jul 2021	6	0	6
Aug 2021	9	0	9
Sep 2021	12	0	12
Oct 2021	5	0	5
Nov 2021	10	6	0	16
Dec 2021	9	1	0	10
Jan 2022	9	0	9
Feb 2022	5	0	5
Mar 2022	6	2	8
Apr 2022	5	0	5
May 2022	3	1	4
Jun 2022	1	1	2
Jul 2022	0
Aug 2022	3	1	0	4
Sep 2022	3	0	3
Oct 2022	2	1	0	3
Nov 2022	4	1	0	5
Dec 2022	3	1	0	4
Jan 2023	5	0	5
Feb 2023	5	3	1	9
Mar 2023	11	0	11
Apr 2023	2	0	2
May 2023	4	1	5
Jun 2023	3	0	3
Jul 2023	5	1	6
Aug 2023	7	1	0	8
Sep 2023	9	1	2	12
Oct 2023	4	0	4
Nov 2023	3	1	3	7
Dec 2023	5	0	5
Jan 2024	6	0	6
Feb 2024	7	1	2	10
Mar 2024	18	1	2	21
Apr 2024	9	1	1	11

Cited

Latest update: 01 May 2024

Commentary on ''Measurements of ice supersaturations exceeding 100% at the cold tropical tropopause'' by E. Jensen et al.

Viewed

Cited

1 citations as recorded by crossref.