<p>Surface active compounds (surfactants) found in atmospheric aerosols can decrease droplet surface tension as they adsorb to the droplet surfaces simultaneously depleting the droplet bulk. These processes may influence the activation properties of aerosols into cloud droplets and investigation of their role in cloud microphysics has been ongoing for decades. In this study, we have used six different approaches documented in the literature to represent surface activity in Köhler calculations predicting cloud droplet activation properties for particles consisting of one of three different moderately surface active organics mixed with ammonium sulphate in different ratios. We find that the different models predict comparable activation properties at small organic mass fractions in the dry particles for all three moderately surface active organics tested, even with large differences in the predicted degree of bulk-to-surface partitioning of the surface active component. However, differences between the models regarding both the predicted critical diameter and supersaturation for the same dry particle size increase with the organic fraction in the particles. Comparison with available experimental data shows that assuming complete bulk-to-surface partitioning of the organic component (total depletion of the bulk) along the full droplet growth curve does not adequately represent the activation properties of particles with high moderate surfactant mass fractions. Accounting for the surface tension depression mitigates some of the effect. Models that include the possibility for partial bulk-to-surface partitioning yield comparable results to the experimental data, even at high organic mass fractions in the particles. The study highlights the need for using thermodynamically consistent model frameworks to treat surface activity of atmospheric aerosols and for firm experimental validation of model predictions across a wide range of states relevant to the atmosphere.</p>